Is 'harry potter is thousands of years old fanfiction' a new concept in the Harry Potter fan community?

Definitely not. In the vast world of Harry Potter fanfiction, the main themes usually revolve around the characters we know and love, their growth, and the magical elements that are already established in the original series. Concepts related to machines are quite far - fetched in this context. While there may be some very niche fanfictions that might touch on it, it's not a common or mainstream idea within the community.

It is likely to be controversial. The Harry Potter series has a large and diverse fan community, and the idea of Harry Potter as a crossdresser goes against the traditional portrayal of the character. Many fans have a strong attachment to the original characters and their identities as presented in the books. This kind of fanfiction may be seen as disrespectful to the source material by some, while others might be more open - minded about exploring different interpretations, but overall it would likely stir up a fair amount of debate.

No. In the vast world of Harry Potter fanfic, the more common themes revolve around Hogwarts, the houses, the magical creatures, and the relationships between the characters. The concept of Harry Potter as a cyborg is very much a niche idea that goes against the grain of the established magical universe. It's not something that would typically gain a large following within the general fan community.

Well, in the large and diverse Harry Potter fan community, different concepts gain different levels of popularity. For the 'harry potter is a pureblood fanfic' idea, it depends on the interests of individual fans. Some fans who are really into the complex world of pureblood wizarding families and their politics might find it very appealing. But others who are more focused on the original story's plot and character relationships as they are might not be as interested. So overall, it's not a concept that's ubiquitously popular, but has its own niche following.

It depends on how you define 'popular'. There are so many different types of fanfiction in the Harry Potter universe. Some concepts gain a lot of traction and are shared widely among fans, but others remain more niche. This 'harry potter is a ghoul fanfiction' might be one of those that only a small subset of fans who are particularly interested in unique or darker interpretations are aware of.

Well, it's a rather strange concept. In the Harry Potter world, there's no established 'blood elemental' concept in the original canon. But in fanfiction, anything can be created. Some might find it interesting as it adds a new and unique twist to the familiar Harry Potter universe. However, others might think it goes too far from the original essence of the story.

Well, it could be. In the normal Harry Potter universe, we have a set timeline. But in fanfiction, anything goes. This concept might bring in new elements such as ancient magic that was lost over time and how Harry, being 2000 years old, has seen the rise and fall of different magical cultures. It's definitely not something you see in the original books.

Well, it's not a very common or legitimate concept. Harry Potter and Starkiller belong to different fictional universes with their own distinct rules and storylines. Combining them in fanfiction might seem odd as they have different magical systems, settings, and overall themes.

Yes, it could be. In the vast world of fanfiction, it's not uncommon for elements of different popular franchises to be combined. Fans might create stories where Naruto characters exist in the Harry Potter universe or vice versa, so in that sense, it could be considered a valid fanfiction concept.

No. Harry Potter and Deathwing are from two completely different fictional universes. Harry Potter is a wizarding world series with its own unique magic system, characters, and storylines, while Deathwing is from the Warcraft universe which has a different set of lore, races, and magic. They don't really blend in a legitimate fanfiction sense.