Sirius and Remus fight over Hermione in fanfiction: What could be the possible reasons?

Their own personal histories could also be a factor. Remus has always been an outsider in some ways because of his werewolf nature, and he might see Hermione as someone who accepts him completely. Sirius, on the other hand, has had a troubled past and Hermione's loyalty and goodness might be very appealing to him. So, they could fight over who 'deserves' her more based on their own self - perceived worth. And also, they might be fighting not just for Hermione but for a sense of normalcy and a future that she represents in their lives.

One possible reason could be jealousy. Maybe one of the Weasleys develops romantic feelings for Hermione and the others don't approve or also have feelings for her. Another reason might be related to her magical abilities. If Hermione has some unique magic or knowledge that the Weasleys think can benefit them or their family in different ways, they could fight over it. For example, her knowledge of ancient spells could be seen as a great asset.

In such fanfictions, their fight over Hermione can have a significant impact on the magical community within the story too. If Remus and Sirius are important figures, their feud can cause unrest. It might also affect Hermione's standing in the wizarding world. For instance, if the fight becomes public knowledge, she could be seen as a source of trouble or a desirable prize. This would then attract other characters' attention, either to protect her or to use her in the power struggle between Remus and Sirius.

One reason could be jealousy. Maybe Ron feels that Harry is getting too close to Hermione and he's afraid of losing her attention. In fanfiction, authors often play with the characters' emotions. Harry, on the other hand, might see Ron as being too possessive of Hermione.

One reason could be love. Hermione is a smart and kind - hearted girl, and the Weasley boys might all develop feelings for her. Jealousy would then be a big factor in their fights.

One reason could be that they might have different interpretations of Harry's character in the fanfiction. Hermione, being logical, may see Harry in a more practical light, while Ron, with his emotional side, could have a different view.

In a fight over Hermione, neither Sirius nor Remus would truly 'win' in a traditional sense. Hermione is an independent and strong - willed character. She wouldn't just be a prize to be won. If they did fight, it would probably end up with Hermione being angry at both of them for treating her like an object. In the end, the real victory would be for them to respect Hermione's own choices and autonomy rather than trying to 'win' her in a fight.

One reason could be that Hermione is under a lot of stress in the fanfic, and she takes it out on Sirius. Also, she might have some misinformation about Sirius that makes her think less of him. For example, if there are rumors going around about Sirius' past actions, Hermione might believe them without really getting to know him better. Another possibility is that Hermione is trying to assert her authority in a situation where she feels it's being challenged, and Sirius just happens to be in her way.

In the realm of fanfiction, the idea of Hermione being Sirius and Remus' daughter might stem from a desire to explore different family dynamics. It could start with a time - traveling incident where the past is altered. Sirius and Remus might have found a way to ensure Hermione's existence in a different timeline. This would completely change the relationships in the Harry Potter universe and open up new storylines for the author to explore, like how Hermione would grow up with two very different fathers, one a werewolf and the other an escaped convict in the eyes of the wizarding world.

Well, in a fanfiction, anything can be made possible. Maybe it could be through some sort of magic gone awry. For example, a spell that was meant to protect Hermione's real parents ended up warping reality and making her seem like Remus and Sirius' daughter. Another idea could be that some dark wizard had a plan to manipulate their genes or magical essence in some way to create this new family connection.