Well, perhaps the fanfiction could start with Riley and Ben being friends who discover that they might both be the potential father of the pregnant girl's baby. They then decide to co - parent, even before knowing who the real father is. They learn about parenting together, attend parenting classes side by side. Along the way, they both develop deeper feelings for the girl. The girl, in turn, sees how committed they are and starts to have feelings for both of them as well. This creates a very unique and complicated relationship dynamic.
In this fanfiction, it could be that Riley and Ben are in a competitive situation to be the best baby daddy. They constantly try to outdo each other in taking care of the pregnant girl. Ben might cook the most nutritious meals for her, while Riley takes her on relaxing walks. As the pregnancy nears its end, they realize that their competition has brought them closer together as friends. They also realize that the most important thing is the well - being of the mother and the baby, not who is the better baby daddy. So they decide to support each other and be there for the girl and the baby in the best way possible.
A simple main plot could be that Riley gets pregnant, and she and Ben have to quickly adjust to the idea of becoming parents. They might struggle with financial concerns, like how to afford a new baby. They also have to think about their living situation, whether they need a bigger place. Their friends could play a big role in helping them through this, like offering advice or babysitting in the future.
In this fanfiction, Riley discovers she's pregnant. Ben might be hesitant at first because he has some insecurities about being a father. However, as time passes, he sees Riley's strength and determination. They go through the usual pregnancy journey together, like going to doctor's appointments, shopping for baby stuff. Their relationship also deepens during this time as they face the challenges and joys of impending parenthood.
The fanfiction could revolve around Ben getting injured and Riley taking care of him. During this time, Riley discovers a more vulnerable side of Ben that she hadn't seen before. Ben, in turn, realizes how much he appreciates Riley's presence in his life. This situation could lead to a romantic development between them. For example, one night when Ben has a fever, Riley stays up all night to take care of him. As he wakes up in the morning, seeing Riley asleep next to his bed, he feels a warmth in his heart that he hadn't felt before.
A great plot for this fanfiction could be that the girl is not sure which one of them is the actual baby daddy, Riley or Ben. She decides to keep the baby regardless. As the pregnancy progresses, both Riley and Ben become more involved in her life. They both start to bond with the unborn baby in different ways. Ben might buy baby clothes and toys, while Riley reads pregnancy and parenting books to be more informed. In the end, it could be revealed through a DNA test who the real father is, or they could decide that it doesn't matter and raise the baby together as a family.
In a fanfiction scenario, Ben and Riley could be at a masquerade ball in their town. They don't recognize each other at first because of the masks. They start dancing and chatting, and there's an instant connection. When they finally take off their masks, they are both surprised and happy, and this event could be the start of a romantic relationship between them.
A possible plot is that Danny has always been a bit of a playboy before Riley got pregnant. But the pregnancy changes his perspective completely. He starts to take care of Riley, cooking for her, and making sure she's comfortable. As the due date approaches, he gets nervous but also excited. He may have a heart - to - heart talk with Riley about their hopes and fears for their future family, and they promise to be there for each other no matter what.
Love and romance also play a big part. Often, the stories will start with them just being connected through the baby, but then they gradually fall in love. For example, in many fanfictions, Ben might realize how strong and amazing Riley is while they are dealing with a baby - related crisis, and that realization can spark his deeper feelings for her. It's a common trope in these stories.
One character that might be popular is an older neighbor. This neighbor could have a lot of experience with raising children and offers wisdom and support to Ben and Riley. They might be the ones who help Ben and Riley resolve a big argument they have over the baby's upbringing. Another popular character could be a daycare provider. Since the baby needs care while Ben and Riley are working or dealing with other things, the daycare provider could be a source of both comic relief and important advice in the fanfiction.
One possible plotline could be about the challenges Ben and Riley face in co - parenting. For example, they might struggle with different parenting styles. Ben could be more laid - back while Riley is more strict. Another plotline could be a love triangle where someone else has feelings for either Ben or Riley, which complicates their relationship as baby daddy and mama. Or perhaps there's a plotline where they have to deal with unexpected family interference in their parenting journey.
The plot could involve a situation where Riley initially believes he is the baby daddy but then doubts start to surface. Danny steps in to support the mother during this turmoil. As they dig deeper into the truth about the baby's paternity, they also discover more about their own relationships and what they truly want in life. Maybe they end up co - parenting regardless of who the biological father is.