What makes 'knock'em dead town' so special in a murder mystery novel?

The setting can create a mood. If it's a gloomy, fog - covered 'knock'em dead town', it sets a spooky atmosphere that makes the murders seem more menacing.

The unique setting of a monastery. It's a place that's supposed to be peaceful and full of piety, so a murder there is a huge contrast. It adds an element of shock and mystery.

The unique concept. It combines the idea of perfume, which is often associated with beauty and luxury, with murder. This contrast makes it stand out.

The mystery. You don't know who's knocking at the door in the story, and when it turns out to be a ghost, it gives you a chill.

The unexpectedness makes it scary. Just like in a 'knock knock' horror story, you don't know who or what is on the other side of the door. It could be a demon, a ghost, or some otherworldly entity. The simple act of knocking is something we associate with normal, friendly visits in real life. But in these stories, it becomes a harbinger of doom.

The characters in the original are already interesting, and in the fanfiction, they can be developed further. Writers can explore different relationships and personalities, which attracts readers. For example, a fanfiction might focus on a side character from the original and give them a more prominent role in the mystery-solving process.

The suspense. In party murder mystery novels, you never know who the killer is. Everyone at the party seems like a suspect.

The suspense. People like to be kept in the dark and try to figure out who the killer is. It's like a mental game.

The mystery within the mystery. Often, not only is there the mystery of who committed the murder, but also the mystery of how the Amish community will react and whether their traditional values will be affected. Since the Amish are a private community, outsiders trying to solve a murder within it face many challenges, like understanding their language, customs, and the relationships between members. All these elements combined make Amish murder mystery novels really interesting.

Murder mystery short stories are popular because they offer a sense of mystery and intrigue. People enjoy trying to solve the puzzle along with the characters. The settings often play a role too. Dark and spooky settings in stories like 'The Cask of Amontillado' add to the overall atmosphere. The complex relationships between the characters also contribute. In some stories, the motives behind the murder can be very interesting, whether it's love, greed, or revenge.