Well, an interesting plot could be an OC who was originally a civilian but got forced into CP9 due to some family secrets. This OC could then struggle between following the harsh orders of CP9 and their own moral compass. They might also form an unlikely alliance with some of the Straw Hat Pirates while on a mission, which would put them in a difficult position within CP9.
Well, perhaps the OC is from a long - lost tribe that has a connection to a hidden treasure. Corazon, being in the Donquixote Pirates, stumbles upon the OC. At first, there's a lot of mistrust, but as they face various challenges together, like dealing with other pirates who also want the treasure or escaping from the Marines, they start to trust each other more and more. And the OC could also have some knowledge about the Will of D that intrigues Corazon.
One idea could be that the Killer OC has a unique devil fruit ability that allows them to control time in a limited area. They could use this to outwit the Straw Hats during an encounter, creating a really intense battle scene.
Another plot could revolve around an OC who is a former victim of Doflamingo's cruel rule. This OC could be on a quest for revenge. They might start by gathering allies who were also affected by Doflamingo and then plan a elaborate scheme to take him down. Along the way, they could face many challenges and obstacles set by Doflamingo and his loyal followers.
One idea could be creating an OC who is a long - lost relative of a Straw Hat member. For example, an OC who is related to Luffy and has a unique form of Haki that they develop in a different way than Luffy. Another idea is an OC who is a marine with a sense of justice that conflicts with the traditional marine views, leading to interesting storylines within the One Piece world. Also, an OC from a new and mysterious island with a special Devil Fruit power that no one has seen before can add a fresh aspect to the fanfiction.
One idea could be that the OC has a special power which Zoro becomes possessive over because he realizes its potential in battles. For example, the OC can sense the weak points of enemies, and Zoro wants to keep this ability within the crew for strategic advantages.
Well, a great plot might be that the OC is an artist who can draw the secrets of the Poneglyphs without actually reading them. Robin is fascinated by this ability and they work together to uncover the true history of the world. Also, perhaps the OC has a connection to Robin's past, like knowing someone who was important to her family, which creates an emotional bond between them.
A great plot idea could be that the OC is a healer who saves Ace's life after a particularly brutal fight. Ace is initially distrustful but as he recovers, he sees the kindness in the OC. They then go on a journey to find a rare herb that can cure a disease that is spreading among the pirates, and along the way, their relationship blossoms.
One idea could be an OC who has a unique Devil Fruit ability that helps the Whitebeard Pirates in a crucial battle. For example, a fruit that can manipulate the weather in a small area to their advantage.
One idea could be an OC who is a gamer in the One Piece world and has the ability to hack into Devil Fruits' powers, creating unique and unexpected combat situations. Another could be an OC gamer who uses their gaming knowledge to outwit the Marines in strategic battles across the Grand Line. Or perhaps an OC who discovers a virtual reality game within the One Piece universe that holds the secrets to ancient powers.
One interesting idea could be unique character backstories for original characters (OCs). For example, an OC with a special power related to a forgotten part of the One Piece world. Another could be new story arcs that explore uncharted islands with their own rules and mysteries. Also, there might be fanfictions that focus on different relationships between the OCs and the existing One Piece characters, like an unexpected friendship or a rivalry that changes the course of the story.