One idea could be that Bella discovers a hidden magical grove in the woods. Another is that she befriends a mysterious forest creature. Maybe she could also find an ancient, forgotten cabin with secrets inside.
In this fanfiction, a great plot could be that Bella stumbles upon a portal in the woods that leads to a different realm. She then has to find her way back while facing various challenges in this new world. Also, she could start a garden in the woods and the plants seem to have a special, almost sentient quality to them.
One idea could be an OC who is a lost princess from a neighboring kingdom. She stumbles into the woods while fleeing from an arranged marriage. In the woods, she meets the familiar characters like Cinderella and Little Red Riding Hood. She teams up with them to face the challenges in the woods, and along the way, she discovers her own hidden powers and a connection to the magic of the woods that no one else knew about.
One idea could be exploring Mae's life before she came back to Possum Springs. Maybe her experiences in college that led to her dropping out. Another could be a story focused on Bea's family business and how she copes with the added pressure. A third option might be a time - travel fanfic where Mae goes back to a crucial moment in the town's history.
A possible plot idea is that the characters from 'Twilight' get lost in the 'Into the Woods' world. Bella could use her special connection with Edward to navigate through the strange and dangerous woods. The Cullens might have to deal with the various fairy - tale creatures, like the witch who could be interested in their unique abilities. This would lead to a lot of conflict and character development.
Another plot idea is to have a character from the modern world somehow time - travel to the 'little house in the woods' setting. This could bring in new ideas and technologies that shock and amaze the original inhabitants, while also creating some comical misunderstandings.
Another plot could involve a time - traveling aspect. A character from the present accidentally travels back to the time when the events of the 'through the woods game' originally took place. They have to figure out how to get back while also dealing with the different rules and threats that existed in that era.
One idea could be exploring Mae's life before she came back to Possum Springs. Maybe her experiences in college that led to her dropping out. Another could be a story about Bea's family history and how it shaped her personality. And also, a fanfiction about Gregg and Angus going on an adventure outside of Possum Springs.
One idea could be that Bella and Hunter get into an argument over a football strategy, but then realize they both have the same goal of winning the big game and end up working together better than ever. Another could be a situation where they accidentally get locked in the school gym overnight and have to rely on each other to get out and also face their feelings for each other during that time. Or perhaps they both enter a local talent show separately and then decide to team up at the last minute to create an amazing performance.
One plot idea could be that Bella and Zach get into an argument over a football strategy, but then they realize they both have the same goal and end up working together better than ever. Another could be a situation where Zach gets injured and Bella has to step up to help him both in his recovery and on the football field. Maybe they also go on a double date with their friends and some comical misunderstandings occur during the date.
One plot idea could be that Bella is transported into the Cinderella story. She uses her modern - day knowledge to help Cinderella in a new way, like teaching her self - defense so she can stand up to her step - sisters. Another could be that Cinderella has some of Bella's traits, like being a bit clumsy at times but still having a heart of gold. A third idea is that Bella discovers that Cinderella's fairy godmother is actually a powerful witch from her own world, and they have to team up to defeat an evil force that threatens both of their worlds.
One idea could be a time - travel plot. Tinga Bella could travel back in time to a key moment in her world's history and have to make choices that change the future. Another could be a crossover with another fictional universe, where she meets new characters and has to adapt to a different set of rules. Or perhaps a story where she loses her powers temporarily and has to rely on her wits and the help of her friends to overcome a powerful enemy.