Is 'harry potter is a crossdresser fanfiction' a popular or controversial concept in the Harry Potter fan community?

I think it's not very popular. The Harry Potter series is mainly about magic, friendship, and good versus evil. The 'deadly sin' concept is quite different in nature. Fans usually prefer fanfictions that stay closer to the original themes of the series, like exploring different relationships between the characters within the magical world or creating new adventures based on the existing plot.

Well, in the large and diverse Harry Potter fan community, different concepts gain different levels of popularity. For the 'harry potter is a pureblood fanfic' idea, it depends on the interests of individual fans. Some fans who are really into the complex world of pureblood wizarding families and their politics might find it very appealing. But others who are more focused on the original story's plot and character relationships as they are might not be as interested. So overall, it's not a concept that's ubiquitously popular, but has its own niche following.

It depends on how you define 'popular'. There are so many different types of fanfiction in the Harry Potter universe. Some concepts gain a lot of traction and are shared widely among fans, but others remain more niche. This 'harry potter is a ghoul fanfiction' might be one of those that only a small subset of fans who are particularly interested in unique or darker interpretations are aware of.

Definitely not. In the vast world of Harry Potter fanfiction, the main themes usually revolve around the characters we know and love, their growth, and the magical elements that are already established in the original series. Concepts related to machines are quite far - fetched in this context. While there may be some very niche fanfictions that might touch on it, it's not a common or mainstream idea within the community.

Well, it's not a very common or legitimate concept. Harry Potter and Starkiller belong to different fictional universes with their own distinct rules and storylines. Combining them in fanfiction might seem odd as they have different magical systems, settings, and overall themes.

I'm not entirely sure. It could be a very niche or even a made - up concept by a small group. Harry Potter and Xehanort are from two very different fictional universes (Harry Potter series and Kingdom Hearts respectively), so it might not be a mainstream or widely recognized fanfiction idea.

This is a highly controversial concept. The Harry Potter franchise has a huge global following. J.K. Rowling created Harry as a symbol of hope, courage and the fight against evil. Making him a crime lord in fanfiction not only goes against the established character traits but also has the potential to distort the positive impact the series has had on generations. It may be popular among a very small subset of fans who like dark and subversive interpretations, but overall it will likely be met with a great deal of opposition from the larger fan community.

This is a highly controversial idea. Harry Potter is the hero who is dedicated to defeating Voldemort. His whole journey is about standing up to the Dark Lord. The idea of him being submissive to Voldemort completely undermines the narrative of the series. Fans usually view Harry as a symbol of resistance and hope, not submissiveness to the main villain.

I'm not really sure if it's a popular concept. It seems like a very strange and unique crossover idea. There might be a small niche of fans who are into both Harry Potter and Shin Godzilla and might create or enjoy such fanfiction, but it's not something that is mainstream in either of the two large fanbases.

Yes, it can be quite popular. In the Harry Potter fanfiction world, exploring Hermione's character in different scenarios, such as being related to the pureblood concept, adds new dimensions to her character. Many fans enjoy seeing how she would interact with the pureblood society, its traditions, and how it might change her relationships within the wizarding world.