What makes it seem like Harry Potter could be a Grimm Fanfic?

Honestly, there's no valid reason to think Harry Potter could be Beetlejuice fanfiction. The Harry Potter series has a deep lore that is firmly rooted in the wizarding world, from the creation of the Philosopher's Stone to the fight against Voldemort. Beetlejuice has its own wacky and unique story that has no relation to the magical institutions and events in Harry Potter. It's just a completely baseless idea that has no real elements to support it.

There's really no good reason for it to be misconstrued as such. They are completely different. Maybe someone who is very confused about different fictional universes might make such a strange claim, but there are no elements in Harry Potter that could realistically be related to Autobots.

The backstories. The Marauders' backstories are so rich and intertwined with Harry's world. For example, Remus Lupin being a werewolf and his relationship with the other Marauders. Also, the fact that Harry inherits the Marauders' Map. All these things create a connection that gives it a fanfiction - like feel.

The setting. Hogwarts is a school for wizards, which is similar to the types of institutions often found in mage fanfiction. It's a place where young magic - users learn and develop their skills. Also, the existence of a hidden magical world parallel to the Muggle world is a common trope in mage - related fictional works.

There are several elements that make Harry Potter seem like Sherlock Holmes fanfiction. Firstly, the idea of a hero on a journey to uncover the truth. Harry's journey to defeat Voldemort involves unravelling many mysteries. Secondly, the use of clues and evidence. In Harry Potter, there are often small details that Harry and his friends pick up on to progress in their mission, similar to how Holmes uses clues to solve cases. And finally, the sense of a larger world with many hidden aspects waiting to be discovered, whether it's the wizarding world or the seedy underbelly of London in Sherlock Holmes stories.

No way. Harry Potter has a very specific set of magic rules, like spells, potions, and the use of magic wands. It also has a well - developed backstory about the wizarding world's history and the fight against Voldemort. Grimm's Fairy Tales are more about moral lessons and often have different types of magic or no magic at all. So Harry Potter can't be a Grimm fanfic.

It could be really interesting. Maybe Harry would create a noble phantasm that has the power of his Patronus. Since his Patronus is a stag, the noble phantasm could be a powerful stag - like entity that can charge at enemies and protect those he cares about. It might also incorporate elements of his Gryffindor courage, being unyielding in the face of danger.

A story might seem true when it incorporates common human experiences and emotions. If the story's conflicts and resolutions are something people can imagine happening in real life, that helps too. And good research or knowledge of the subject matter can make it more convincing.

One unique feature is the darker tone. Grimm tales are often dark, and when combined with Harry Potter, it adds a new level of seriousness and danger to the story. For example, the magic might have more unpredictable and dangerous consequences.

On one hand, 'Shantaram' seems like it could be fact because it has elements that are based on real places and cultures. The author's in - depth knowledge of Mumbai's underworld, its people, and its culture is evident. But on the other hand, the highly dramatized events and the almost superhuman abilities of the main character suggest that it is fiction. For instance, the main character gets involved in all sorts of dangerous and complex situations and always manages to come out on top in a rather unbelievable way, which is a common trait in fictional stories.