In the 'Dumbledore stops Snape from bullying Harry' fanfic, how does Dumbledore initially become aware of Snape's bullying of Harry?

Snape might be given a warning by Dumbledore at first. Just a simple 'stop this behavior or else' kind of warning.

In the fanfiction, Snape could protect Harry from Dumbledore by using his skills in potions. For example, he might create a potion that hides Harry's magical signature from Dumbledore's detection. Or he could use his knowledge of the Dark Arts to counter any spells or charms that Dumbledore might use to keep tabs on Harry. Snape is very intelligent and resourceful, so he could find various ways to physically and magically shield Harry from Dumbledore.

One reason could be that Snape has his own complex sense of loyalty. He may feel that Dumbledore's plans for Harry are too dangerous or not in Harry's best interest in some ways. He has a long - standing relationship with Harry's mother, Lily, and perhaps through that connection, he wants to safeguard Harry from any harm that might come from Dumbledore's actions or decisions.

Typically, it portrays Dumbledore as a manipulator. He's seen as using Snape's feelings for Lily and Harry's role in the fight against Voldemort for his own purposes, rather than having pure intentions.

In many such fanfictions, Dumbledore might comfort Snape by reminding him of his good deeds. For example, he could say that Snape's role as a double agent is crucial for the greater good. Dumbledore might also offer a sympathetic ear, listening to Snape's inner turmoil about his past actions and his love for Lily. By validating Snape's feelings and his importance in the fight against Voldemort, Dumbledore provides comfort.

Perhaps Harry misinterprets Dumbledore's cryptic messages. Dumbledore often gives rather mysterious instructions, and if Harry takes them the wrong way, it can lead to him messing up the plans. Like he might think Dumbledore wants him to do one thing when in fact it's the opposite, and so he goes ahead and does the wrong thing, thus ruining the plan.

The bullying can be a central conflict in the fanfiction. It can change the dynamic between Harry and other characters too. For instance, his friends might be more protective of him, or some characters might side with Snape, causing more division. This can make the story more complex and engaging. In addition, it can be used to explore themes of justice and standing up for oneself in the fanfiction world.

Dumbledore can hurt Snape in fanfiction by taking advantage of his love for Lily. He might use this love as a tool to manipulate Snape into doing dangerous tasks. For example, making Snape spy on Voldemort, knowing full well that Snape's life is at risk every time he does so.

There are indeed. Fanfiction often takes the existing characters and relationships and turns them on their heads. In this case, Snape helping Harry against Dumbledore could be a result of Snape's long - held grudges against Dumbledore's actions or decisions. It's a creative way to explore the gray areas of these beloved characters.

The fanfic changes the perception of Dumbledore's character in that it shatters the image of his infallibility. He is no longer the perfect headmaster and guide. Stealing from Harry shows that he is capable of moral wrongs, and this can lead to a more nuanced understanding of his character, where he is not simply all - good or all - bad but a mix of both, with his own motives and desires that might not always align with what is best for Harry.