Definitely not. Although punishments seem harsh at first glance, they can be beneficial. For example, if a student is punished for being late to class repeatedly by having to help the teacher with some tasks before class for a while. This can make the student more punctual. Another instance is when students are punished for not participating in group activities. They are then made to lead a group project. This forces them to improve their social skills and teamwork. So, boarding school punishment stories are not always negative; they can be a form of character building.
Not always. There are cases where the punishment served as a learning experience. Take a student who was punished for not cleaning his or her part of the dormitory. The punishment might be to clean the whole dormitory for a week. This can teach the student responsibility and the importance of following rules. Also, when students are punished for talking during study hours and are then given a chance to be in a quiet study environment alone, they may learn better study habits. So, boarding school punishment stories can have positive aspects too.