Why would Dumbledore underestimate Harry Potter fanfiction?

In my opinion, Dumbledore would underestimate Harry Potter fanfiction. Fanfiction is a realm where fans take the original story and run with it in all kinds of directions. There are fanfictions that change the personalities of characters, create new storylines that deviate greatly from the original. Dumbledore, who is bound by the original narrative and his role in it, may not understand the significance of this new wave of creativity that fanfiction represents. He may see it as a distortion of the world he knows rather than a celebration and expansion of it.

Well, one reason could be that it's often seen as just a derivative work. People might think it can't be as good as the original series. But they're wrong. Fanfiction allows for so many creative interpretations. It can explore different character backstories, relationships in ways that the original might not have. It gives fans a chance to be creative and add their own ideas to the Harry Potter universe.

For the sake of creating a unique plot. The 'Harry Potter' series has a well - established story, and by changing such a fundamental relationship as Harry and Dumbledore's, the author can draw in readers who are interested in seeing a fresh take on the familiar world. It can also open up new storylines that might not have been possible in the original series, like how Hogwarts functions without Harry having Dumbledore as a guiding figure.

Maybe he takes it out of a sense of duty. Harry might feel that he needs to carry on Dumbledore's legacy and that using his wand is a way to do that. He could believe that Dumbledore's wand holds the power to defeat the remaining threats to the wizarding world.

Maybe it's a plot twist to create more drama and conflict. Fanfiction authors often come up with wild ideas to make the story more exciting.

In some fanfictions, Dumbledore might bow out of respect for a powerful magical entity or a person with extraordinary abilities. It could also be a sign of his humility in the face of a situation where he realizes he is not the most knowledgeable or powerful.

It could be because of a deep-seated grudge or misunderstanding. Maybe Harry felt betrayed by Dumbledore's actions or decisions.

Perhaps Harry was feeling betrayed or misunderstood and wanted to express his strong emotions directly to Dumbledore through a howler. This could be a way to make his point and demand a response.

In some fanfiction, Harry might not trust Dumbledore because the author wants to explore different power dynamics. Maybe they show Dumbledore keeping too many secrets, like about Harry's past or the true nature of the threats he faces. This secrecy can make Harry feel manipulated and thus lead to a lack of trust.

Well, there are several reasons. Dumbledore is this all - knowing figure in the original series, but in fanfiction, his actions can be seen as manipulative. He might be making decisions for Harry without really considering Harry's feelings or wishes. Also, Dumbledore's grand schemes might not always be in Harry's best interest. Harry might realize this and get fed up. For instance, if Dumbledore is using Harry as a pawn in a bigger battle against Voldemort, Harry would likely be angry when he figures it out. And Dumbledore's failure to prevent certain tragedies, like the death of Sirius, could also be a reason for Harry's disillusionment.