The key elements include its origin as a building constructed in the 1850s by Thomas Whaley. The numerous reports of paranormal activities such as apparitions, strange noises, and objects moving on their own. Moreover, the historical events that took place on the site prior to the house's construction contribute to the overall story. For example, the hanging which is thought to have left some sort of 'imprint' on the place, making it seem haunted.
One key element is its construction by Thomas Whaley. Another is the reports of hauntings. Also, the fact that a hanging occurred on the property before the house was built is important.
Well, first of all, the construction of the Old Town Whaley House by Thomas Whaley is a fundamental element. Then, the hauntings are a major part. People's experiences of seeing ghosts, hearing voices, and feeling strange presences play a big role. The history of the land before the house was there, like the hanging, adds to the mystery. And the house's preservation over the years also matters, as it allows the story to continue and be told. It all combines to create this unique and spooky story about the Old Town Whaley House.