One plot idea could be that James and Edward get into a friendly competition to see who can pull the most cars in a day. Another could be that they have to work together to rescue a stranded train during a storm. Maybe there's a situation where James gets in trouble for being too boastful and Edward has to help him learn a lesson about humility.
Well, a really interesting plot could be that a new, shiny engine arrives on Sodor. James gets jealous thinking he'll be replaced as the 'fancy' engine, but Edward helps him realize his own unique value. They could also go on an adventure to a far - off part of Sodor that they've never been to before, facing various challenges along the way like broken tracks and difficult terrains.
A great plot for a James and Edward fanfiction could involve a misunderstanding. For example, James misinterprets something Edward says and gets angry at him. This causes a rift between them. However, as they go about their daily tasks, they start to realize that they miss each other's company. Eventually, they have a heart - to - heart conversation and clear up the misunderstanding, strengthening their friendship in the process.
Perhaps there could be a story where Thomas and Edward compete in a friendly race. Along the way, they both learn important lessons about sportsmanship and friendship. For example, when one of them has a minor accident, the other stops to help, realizing that winning isn't everything.
They could get lost in an old, abandoned part of the railway. Thomas might be a bit scared at first, but Percy stays calm. Together, they explore the area, find old railway artifacts, and then figure out a way to get back to their normal tracks. It would be a story of discovery and courage.
There might be a fanfiction where Edward has to deal with a strange malfunction that gives him unique abilities. For example, he could suddenly be able to understand the thoughts of all the other engines. This would lead to some very interesting interactions and situations as he tries to keep this a secret while also using it to help his friends.
One interesting story could be about Edward and Emily working together to rescue a stranded train. They use their combined strength and smarts to get the job done.
One idea could be an OC engine that comes from a far - off land and has unique abilities, like being able to run on solar power in addition to steam. This engine could face challenges in adapting to the Sodor railway's rules and ways of working.
James is often prideful and Edward is more kind - hearted. In a fanfiction, their different reactions to praise can show this. When the Fat Controller compliments them, James might puff up with pride while Edward just smiles modestly.
Another plot could involve Edward making new friends in the town. These friends could be outcasts like him, and together they form a sort of club. They could then work on projects to beautify the outskirts of the town that have been neglected.
One common plot idea is exploring his past more in - depth, like his time at the military academy. It could show his relationships with other students and how he developed his skills and personality.
One idea could be exploring Edward Mordrake's backstory more in - depth. Maybe his life before the whole 'two - faced' situation, his family, and what led him to become the tragic figure he is. Another could be a modern - day encounter with someone who has a special ability to communicate with him.
One idea could be that Edward, as a cop, is assigned to protect a key witness. During this time, he discovers a complex web of secrets and has to fight against both the criminals who want to silence the witness and some corrupt colleagues. Another plot could be Edward investigating a series of mysterious murders in the city where all the evidence points to a supernatural force. He has to overcome his disbelief in the supernatural to solve the case. And also, Edward could be a rookie cop who gets involved in a big drug - bust operation and has to prove himself to his more experienced partners.