Disgust can also be an emotion. If the horror story involves grotesque details, like a description of a rotting corpse, it can make you feel disgusted. This is a common reaction in horror stories that rely on gore to create an impact.
Fear is the most obvious emotion. When reading or hearing a horror story, the unknown elements, spooky characters or events can trigger this feeling. For instance, if there's a sudden jump scare in the story, it can make your heart race with fear.
The most frightening elements could be the unexpected twists. For example, if the story suddenly reveals that the friendly neighbor is actually the villain all along. It catches you off - guard and sends a shiver down your spine.
Surprise. Since fanfictions often take unexpected turns, they would be caught off guard by new storylines or characterizations.
There could be a mixture of fear and excitement. Fear because they know how fragile a newborn is and excited to start this new chapter of life. They might be thinking about all the things they will do with their daughter as she grows up.
He could feel concern. Since Bella is a human and often in a vulnerable position, Jasper would be worried about her safety.
Sharing your feelings about the story with others can also help. Discussing what scared you the most and hearing their perspectives can make the fear seem less intense. For example, if you talk to a friend who has a different view on the scary parts, it can change how you perceive it.
Fear, of course. It's the most obvious one. When you read about a terrifying monster or a creepy situation, your heart might start to race a bit.
Sometimes, there can be a sense of disappointment. For example, if you had high hopes for a Sim's career in the story and then something goes wrong, like they get fired unjustly. This can make you disappointed, not just for the Sim but also because it might ruin the story arc you had in mind for them.
Anakin might feel a sense of unease mixed with pride. Padme would probably feel joy.
Surprise. He would be amazed at how much he has changed over time.
He'd probably be a bit of shocked. Since fanfiction often contains things that are quite different from what he knows. For example, if it shows a different future for his friends, it would be unexpected for him.