Why do some people write 'Harry Potter bashing Dumbledore fanfic'?

Some fans write it because they feel Dumbledore has some controversial aspects that the original books didn't fully explore. They want to dig deeper into his character and show the darker side that they think exists.

There could be a few reasons. Perhaps they have different interpretations of the characters. For example, they might think Dumbledore was too secretive and Hermione too overbearing at times. However, this doesn't justify bashing them. It could also be that they just want to create shock value or get attention with their fanfics. But in general, it goes against the essence of the original story.

Some fans write it because they feel Dumbledore made a lot of morally ambiguous decisions. For example, his use of Snape was really rough on Snape. He made Snape endure a lot while using him as a spy. Fans might not like this and write bashing fanfics to express their dissatisfaction.

It could be that they simply want to explore different character dynamics. In the original books, Dumbledore is a very powerful and respected figure. By bashing him in fanfiction, they can create new power balances and relationships within the Harry Potter universe. This allows for a fresh take on the story and can lead to interesting character development that wasn't possible in the original story.

There are several reasons. One is that they may have a different vision of the story. They might feel that Ron and Hermione overshadowed other characters in the original and want to give those other characters more room to shine. Another reason could be that they want to create a more edgy or controversial story. Bashing well - loved characters like Ron and Hermione can attract attention and start discussions among fans. It can also be a form of self - expression, where they put their own thoughts about the characters and the story into a new written form, even if it goes against the general perception of the original series.

There could be a few reasons. One might be that they want to create a more edgy or alternative story. By bashing a well - liked character like Molly Weasley, they think they can attract readers who are interested in seeing a different side. Also, some writers may have personal biases against certain character traits she has, like her strictness or her over - protectiveness. However, these are often misinterpretations of her character as she was acting out of love and care most of the time. It's important to note that while they have the right to write these, it doesn't mean it's a fair representation of the character.

Some fans might feel that Dumbledore was too manipulative in the original series. They create these fanfictions to explore an alternative view where his actions are not excused.

Some people write these fanfics because they feel Dumbledore had too much control in the original story. They see Lord Potter as a powerful character who could have made different choices without Dumbledore's interference.

Some people write such fanfiction because they want to explore different perspectives, even if they are negative. Maybe they didn't like how these characters were developed in the original series and decided to create their own versions where they are not so heroic or likable.

Some write it because they feel that James Potter's actions as a bully towards Snape in the original books were not fully addressed. They want to explore the consequences of his actions more deeply.