Well, Homestuck might be considered good because it has a complex and engaging story with unique characters. It builds a rich world that draws readers in. As for metafiction being seen as bad, some might think it's too self - referential and can be confusing. It often breaks the fourth wall in a way that disrupts the traditional storytelling flow, making it less accessible to some readers.
Homestuck has a large and dedicated fanbase because it offers a lot in terms of plot twists, character development, and cultural references. It's a story that can be both deep and fun at the same time. On the other hand, metafiction is often regarded as bad fiction because it can be seen as pretentious. It may assume a level of knowledge from the reader about literary concepts that not everyone has. Metafiction also tends to play with the boundaries of what a story should be, and not all readers appreciate that departure from the norm, whereas Homestuck manages to be innovative without feeling overly alienating.
Homestuck is good because it has a great deal of depth. There are multiple storylines that interweave in interesting ways. Metafiction is considered bad by some because it can seem like it's trying too hard to be clever. It can over - complicate things with its self - awareness. Homestuck, in contrast, is more straightforward in its delivery of an exciting and complex story.
Fiction isn't bad. It depends on how you look at it. For some, it might seem bad if it promotes negative values or is too violent. But mostly, it's a form of escape and creativity.
Some might think fiction is bad because it can sometimes be seen as a waste of time or an escape from reality instead of dealing with real-world issues.
Modern fiction might be seen as bad because it can be too formulaic. Plus, the quality of writing might not be up to par, and the characters and plots might feel rushed or underdeveloped.
One reason why fan fiction is regarded as bad is that it can potentially violate copyright laws if not handled properly. Another issue is that it might stray too far from the established canon of the original work, causing confusion among fans.
Fiction isn't necessarily bad for you. It can offer entertainment, expand your imagination, and provide different perspectives.
It might be that some YA fiction has weak plots or unconvincing characters. That could be a reason for the negative perception.
I don't think it's bad at all. It's a cult classic with unique storytelling and memorable characters.
The perception that historical fiction is bad often stems from concerns like poor character development or a lack of authenticity in depicting the era. Sometimes, it might just not engage the reader or viewer effectively.
I think it's all a matter of personal taste. Some people might not like the nonlinear storytelling or the violence in it.