I haven't come across a 'Harry Potter Punished for Being Gay' fanfiction myself. But if it exists, it could be a way for the author to make a statement about intolerance in the wizarding society. However, it would also be a shock to many fans who are used to the traditional themes of the 'Harry Potter' books. Also, considering J.K. Rowling's statements in the past which have been controversial regarding the transgender community, this kind of fanfiction could be a reaction or a completely independent exploration of themes of sexual orientation within the 'Harry Potter' universe.
It's a very interesting and complex concept. On one hand, it could be a powerful way to explore themes of discrimination and prejudice in the wizarding world, similar to how the original books explored themes of blood - purity and bigotry. On the other hand, it might be seen as a rather extreme deviation from the original story. The 'Harry Potter' series has always been about acceptance in many forms, but this would be a very specific and potentially controversial way to expand on that idea.
One main idea is equality. It tries to eliminate the hierarchical differences in the wizarding world. For instance, no more special treatment for pure - blood families.
One possible scenario could be that Voldemort punishes Harry Potter by using the Cruciatus Curse on him. In the wizarding world, this is a very cruel form of torture. Another situation might be that Voldemort imprisons Harry in a dark and desolate place, like the dungeons of Malfoy Manor. He could also force Harry to watch as he harms his friends, which would be a psychological form of punishment for Harry, who values his friends highly.
The allure of Harry Potter Severus Snape gay fanfiction lies in the novelty of it. It takes a well - known character like Snape and gives him a different kind of relationship dynamic. Fans are always curious to see how their favorite characters would behave in situations not depicted in the original work.
A gay Sirius Black fanfic might focus on his life outside of Hogwarts as well. He could be part of a wizarding community that is more open - minded about homosexuality. The story could show his journey of finding love and acceptance among his peers, while also dealing with the prejudices that still exist in some parts of the wizarding world.
Harry would likely be defiant at first. He has a strong sense of justice and would not easily submit to Voldemort's punishments. For example, if Voldemort uses the Cruciatus Curse, Harry would probably try to resist the pain and not show weakness.
Another factor is the sense of inclusivity. In the original Harry Potter series, there is not much representation in terms of LGBTQ+ relationships. Gay fanfics fill this gap and allow fans who identify as part of the community to see themselves in the world of Hogwarts. It creates a more diverse and relatable Hogwarts for a wider range of readers.
There is no official 'gay evil Harry Potter story' in the original Harry Potter series. J.K. Rowling's work focuses on themes like friendship, courage, and the battle against dark magic, not on such inappropriate and untrue concepts.
One plot idea could be Harry struggling to fit in at first in Slytherin because of the house's reputation for dark magic, but then he discovers the true values of loyalty and cunning within it. He could form an unlikely friendship with a pure - blood Slytherin who helps him see that not all in Slytherin are bad. Another idea is that Harry uses his newfound Slytherin traits to outwit Voldemort in a different way than in the original story, perhaps by using more stealth and manipulation.
Perhaps Harry is adopted by a Muggle family who are aware of the wizarding world. They could be a family of scientists who study magic from a scientific perspective. Harry would grow up with a unique understanding of magic, seeing it both as a wonder of the wizarding world and something that can be analyzed. This might make his time at Hogwarts very interesting as he tries to blend these two views of magic.