Perhaps the story is about a group of hikers who find a toe in the middle of the forest. They take it with them, not realizing it's cursed. Soon, they start getting lost even though they know the area well, and they hear strange whispers that seem to be coming from the toe. As time passes, they begin to have hallucinations of a person missing that toe chasing them.
One possible plot could be that a person wakes up to find a toe in their bed, and then they start experiencing a series of bad luck and creepy events like seeing shadowy figures around their house.
One possible theme could be fear of the unknown. Since it's a monster, we don't know what it really looks like or what it's capable of. Another theme might be body parts as a source of horror. The focus on the toe gives an unusual and somewhat creepy aspect.
One possible theme could be the fear of the unknown. Since we don't know much about this toe, it could represent something mysterious and scary that the old man has to deal with.
In another ending, a brave person decides to help the corpse. They search everywhere and manage to find a toe that looks like hers. When they give it to her, she is so grateful that she uses her last bit of power to protect the person from all the other evils in the haunted place, and then she peacefully ascends to the afterlife.
One possible plot could be that a child wakes up one day to find that all of his teeth have turned black and are rotting away. But when he tries to touch them, they feel as hard as steel. And every night, he can hear his teeth whispering to him, saying strange and menacing things.
Perhaps in the 'the carpet scary story', the carpet was made from the skin of a creature in a dark ritual. When it is placed in a room, it starts to cause hallucinations to those around it. The family members begin to see their worst fears manifested on the carpet and slowly lose their sanity as the carpet seems to have a malevolent power over them. It could be that they have to figure out a way to destroy the carpet before it completely consumes them.
Perhaps the big man is a cursed figure. He was once a normal man but was cursed by an evil witch. Now, he has a grotesque appearance and a terrifying presence. He lives in a haunted forest, and anyone who gets lost in the forest will encounter him. He chases them through the trees, his large footsteps echoing in the stillness of the forest.
One scary element could be the unexpected and grotesque events that occur in the toe story. For example, there might be some sort of strange transformation related to the toe that is both disturbing and frightening.
The sense of the unknown around it. For example, where did the hairy toe come from? Is it part of something bigger or more sinister? And if it starts to move on its own, like it has a life of its own, that's really scary. Also, the physical features such as the hair and if it's dirty or discolored can add to the horror factor. If it leaves some kind of mark or trail as it moves, it makes the whole situation seem more real and terrifying.
Well, it could be a cruel prank gone wrong. Maybe some mean kids set up a dangerous trap and the girl accidentally walked into it. Another reason could be that she was in a haunted place and some evil spirit caused her to lose her toe as part of a curse.
The hairiness of the toe is part of what makes it scary. It's not a normal, clean - looking toe. It's this hairy, unknown thing that gives an icky feeling.