What are the reasons why 'Harry Potter abused sister' should not be a theme in fanfiction?

It could be that they misinterpreted the characters or the world of Harry Potter. Maybe they wanted to explore a very different and 'edgy' take on the story, but they went too far. Another possibility is that they have some personal issues or experiences that they are inappropriately projecting onto the fanfic, but this doesn't make it okay.

Firstly, it's a form of violence that is not in line with the overall tone of the 'Harry Potter' series. The series is mainly about magic and positive relationships. Secondly, it goes against the characters' personalities. Harry and Ginny have a loving relationship in the original work, not one based on such cruel behavior. Thirdly, it's not suitable for the younger audiences who are also part of the 'Harry Potter' fan base.

Well, it might be because some fans feel that Slytherin has been somewhat demonized in the original books. So, they create fanfiction where Slytherin is the victim of abuse, perhaps as a way to give the house more depth and sympathy. Also, the idea of abuse can create a lot of drama and conflict, which are elements that make a story interesting. Fanfiction writers might be using this concept to attract readers who are interested in more complex and edgy storylines. Additionally, it could be a form of exploring the morality and ethics within the Harry Potter universe in a very extreme way.

It could be due to the author's creative choice to add drama or explore darker themes.

It could be because the author wanted to explore a darker side of the character or create more drama.

A 'Harry Potter Erotic Novel' should not exist because the 'Harry Potter' story is a classic in the realm of children's and young adult literature. It has created a magical world full of wonder and adventure. Erotic content has no place in this world as it would corrupt the pure and innocent nature of the story. The series has been a source of inspiration for many, and introducing such inappropriate content would be disrespectful to the millions of fans, the author, and the entire 'Harry Potter' community. It would also be a violation of copyright laws if it was not an official creation, which it never would be as it goes against the very essence of the series.

There should not be any such fanfic. The Harry Potter series is about friendship, courage and magic, not about abuse. This kind of concept goes against the positive values that the original work promotes. It is also unethical and can be very disturbing to the fans who love the original story.

I'm not aware of any such fanfiction that would be appropriate. Abuse is a very serious and inappropriate topic, and it goes against the positive spirit of the Harry Potter series. J.K. Rowling's world is about friendship, courage, and magic, not about such dark and unethical themes.

One reason could be the extreme hardships the characters face in the original story. For example, Harry has lost his parents, faced Voldemort numerous times, and seen many friends die. In fanfiction, this could be amplified to a point where a character feels they have no will to live. Another aspect could be related to the sense of isolation. Some characters, like Snape, were always sort of alone in their struggles, and in fanfiction, this could lead to a loss of the will to live.

Maybe some fanfiction authors just like to explore extremely dark and unexpected scenarios. They want to break the traditional image of the characters to create a unique and controversial story.