To some extent, they are. While the Amish are known for their religious and simple lifestyle, these ghost stories are part of the fabric of their community. They might not be as central as their religious beliefs, but they are shared among families and neighbors. The stories can also be a way for the community to bond, as they sit around and share these spooky tales. It's also possible that these stories have been influenced by the broader cultural environment around the Amish, but they have taken on their own unique Amish flavor over time.
Well, the Amish ghost stories can be considered part of their cultural heritage. They are not something that the Amish promote in the same way as their religious values, but they are still part of the stories that are told within the community. These stories often reflect the Amish relationship with the land and their history. For instance, a ghost story about an old house might be related to the family who once lived there and the events that took place in that location. The stories also add a layer of mystery and wonder to the Amish culture, which is otherwise quite practical and focused on daily life and religious observance.