One possible plot could be Percy dealing with PTSD from Tartarus while trying to fit into high school life. He might have nightmares that disrupt his school days and struggle to make friends who can understand his past traumas.
Perhaps there's a new villain, a powerful sorcerer who has a vendetta against Percy. The sorcerer discovers that Percy is now at high school and decides to target the school. He uses his magic to create illusions and manipulate the minds of the students and faculty, turning them against Percy. The sorcerer might also be after the secrets Percy learned in Tartarus, thinking it can give him more power.
One possible plot could be Percy and Zoe facing numerous dangerous monsters in Tartarus. They might have to rely on each other's unique abilities. For example, Percy's control over water could help them cross certain deadly rivers while Zoe's hunting skills could be used to fend off the approaching beasts.
One possibility could be Percy's struggle to survive the harsh conditions. He might have to find new ways to use his powers in Tartarus. For example, the strange and dark magic there could either enhance or limit his abilities. He could also form alliances with unexpected creatures. Maybe he teams up with some of the ancient and terrifying monsters that live there, but they have a common enemy, so they work together for a time.
Well, one possibility could be Percy facing his inner demons. In Tartarus alone, he might have to deal with the memories of his past failures and the fear that comes with being in such a desolate place. He could encounter strange and terrifying creatures that test his combat skills and his will to survive.
In some fanfictions, Annabeth and Percy might struggle with PTSD. They could have nightmares about their time in Tartarus. Percy might be overly protective of Annabeth, and they may need time to heal their emotional wounds together.
One challenge could be dealing with the trauma. Tartarus is a terrifying place, and Percy might have nightmares that disrupt his school life. He could also find it hard to relate to his classmates who have no idea what he's been through.
Perhaps Percy has to go to Tartarus alone because he believes it's the only way to save his friends. In Tartarus, he might encounter old foes who are now even more powerful. He has to rely on his wits and his skills with his sword, Riptide. He could also make unexpected alliances with some of the creatures there in order to survive and achieve his goal.
In this fanfiction, Percy might also have to deal with his own sanity. Growing up in Tartarus, the constant threat and the dark, desolate place could be a huge mental strain. He could struggle with nightmares and hallucinations, and part of the plot could be about him overcoming these mental challenges while trying to find a way back to the world above.
The plot might involve Percy having to protect the child from the various horrors of Tartarus. Maybe he has to fight off monsters while trying to find a way to get the child out safely.
Well, one possibility is that Percy has to deal with the various monstrous creatures in Tartarus. He might form alliances with some of the less evil ones to maintain order. Maybe he uses his powers over water in unique ways in the dark and chaotic environment of Tartarus.