Well, one reason could be the way the story is told. It has a certain charm and simplicity in its basic premise that can be associated with fairy tales. A young boy discovers he has special powers and is taken to a magical place. This is a common trope in fairy stories. Also, the good - versus - evil theme, which is often central in fairy tales, is also a major part of Harry Potter. However, this view is rather simplistic as Harry Potter is a much more complex and multi - faceted story.
Some people might consider it so because of the presence of magical elements. Things like the magic spells, the magical creatures, and the hidden magical world all seem like elements that could be in a fairy fanfiction. For instance, the idea of a school for wizards hidden from the Muggle world is very much like a fairy - tale concept.
People may think Harry Potter is a fairy fanfiction due to the sense of wonder and magic it evokes. Just as fairy tales often have a touch of the otherworldly, Harry Potter has Hogwarts, a place full of mystery and magic. The use of magic for everyday things, like making objects fly or changing appearance, is similar to the kind of magic seen in fairy - related stories. Also, the presence of mythical beasts gives it a fairy - tale like feel.
There could be a few reasons. One might be that they have been influenced by anti - 'Harry Potter' propaganda. Some groups oppose the series because of its popularity among the youth and the fact that it features magic. But in reality, the 'Harry Potter' series has positive messages about love, loyalty, and sacrifice. It's a story that has inspired generations to be brave and stand up against injustice, not something that is evil fanfiction.
Well, it could be for shock value. Writers might think that by creating a heartless version of the 'Harry Potter' universe, they can get more attention from readers. For example, if they write a story where Harry is a heartless killer, it's so different from the kind - hearted Harry we know that it might draw in people who are curious about this extreme deviation. Another reason could be that they are tired of the typical 'good always wins' narrative and want to create a more complex and morally ambiguous world.
Those who say 'harry potter is a devil fanfiction' are likely to be influenced by unfounded superstition or religious extremism. The series has inspired generations of readers to be brave, to stand up for what is right, and to cherish their friends. It has also contributed to the growth of a global community of fans who share a love for the books and movies. There is nothing devilish about it at all.
It could be a way for writers to express their own views on the wizarding world. For example, if they think the Hogwarts system has flaws, having Harry drop out allows them to show how the system could be improved or how a character can thrive outside of it. Also, it gives more freedom to create unique relationships between characters that might not have been possible in the original story.
Some people write 'Harry Potter mpreg fanfiction' to explore different aspects of the characters. It allows them to add new and unexpected storylines to the well - known world of Harry Potter.
Another reason could be for shock value. Writers know that the Harry Potter series has a large and dedicated fan base, and creating a story where the main character is abused can attract attention. However, this should be done with care as it can also be offensive or disturbing to many fans who love the original positive and inspiring nature of the series.
It could also be a form of catharsis for the writers. If they are going through a tough time in their own lives, writing about depressing scenarios in the Harry Potter universe allows them to express their own feelings in a creative and somewhat removed way. They can project their own sense of hopelessness or sadness onto the characters they love.
One reason is that there's an overwhelming amount of it. With so much fanfiction available, the quality varies greatly. A lot of it is just poorly written, but still gets attention because of the Harry Potter name. So people might see all this sub - par work and think the whole fanfiction side of Harry Potter is overrated.
Some write it because they feel that James Potter's actions as a bully towards Snape in the original books were not fully addressed. They want to explore the consequences of his actions more deeply.
People write this type of fanfiction because it offers a fresh perspective. It allows them to break away from the traditional magic - centered storylines. They can explore how a character like Harry, without magic, would interact with the wizarding world.