What are the main points in John T Irwin's stance against detective fiction?

His view might make some readers more critical of detective fiction. If a respected figure like Irwin is against it, some readers may start to question the value of the genre they previously enjoyed.

Articles against fan fiction may argue that it undermines the integrity of the original work. The original creators have a specific vision for their work, and fan fiction can deviate from that in ways that they may not approve. Also, from a legal perspective, it can be considered a form of copyright infringement. Fan fiction writers may not have the right to use the intellectual property of the original work, which can lead to legal disputes. Moreover, it might create confusion among the audience about what is the official story and what is fan - made content.

In '20 rules of detective fiction', there are important aspects like the criminal must be someone mentioned in the early part of the story. This gives a sense of fairness as the reader can suspect those characters from the get - go. Also, the means of detection should be rational. No far - fetched or illogical methods should be used to figure out who the culprit is. And the detective himself should not turn out to be the criminal in a way that is not hinted at all through the story.

One main point could be the character archetypes in detective fiction. The detective as the hero, with their own quirks and flaws. Another might be the nature of the mysteries themselves, how they are crafted to keep the reader guessing. And finally, the way detective fiction reflects the real - world social issues, even if in a somewhat veiled manner.

There are several stigmas. Firstly, it can be stigmatized as a genre for the masses rather than the elite. This is because detective fiction is often widely accessible and popular. Secondly, there's a view that it doesn't contribute much to the literary canon. Since the focus is on the mystery and its solution, some believe it doesn't explore complex human emotions or social issues deeply. Finally, the predictability of some detective stories, with their standard plot devices, has led to the stigma that it's a less sophisticated form of writing.

One main point is the distinction between the two storylines in detective fiction: the story of the crime itself and the story of the investigation. The former exists before the narrative begins and the latter is what unfolds during the narrative.

His detective fictions often have a strong sense of mystery. The plots are designed to keep readers guessing until the end.

Marsellus Wallace has a powerful and authoritative stance. He's the one in control in the criminal underworld shown in the movie. His stance is that of a man who demands respect and obedience, and he won't tolerate any kind of betrayal or disrespect towards him.

One main point could be Auden's view on the structure of detective fiction. He might have analyzed how the typical setup, with a mystery, suspects, and the detective's investigation, works. Another point could be his take on the character of the detective. Often, detectives in such fiction have unique personalities and methods of deduction.

John Mackintosh's detective fiction often features complex mysteries. His stories typically have well - developed characters. The settings are usually vivid and add to the overall atmosphere of the mystery.