There could be a few reasons. Some might be trying to be edgy or different in the fanfic community. They think by creating something so out - of - the - ordinary and negative like this, they can stand out. Others might have misinterpreted the characters so deeply that they think this is a valid 'alternative' exploration. But really, it's a very inappropriate and untrue - to - the - source - material take on Edward and Bella.
It could be that a very small number of people have a warped view of the characters. Instead of seeing the love and positive aspects of Edward and Bella's relationship, they want to explore a negative and inappropriate side for some strange or deviant reasons. However, this is not in line with the general perception of the story and its characters.
One reason could be a desire for a more edgy or non - traditional take on the popular Edward and Bella relationship. Some people might want to explore a darker side of their dynamic that goes against the typical romantic narrative.
One reason could be the exploration of dark or taboo themes in literature. Some authors might be interested in delving into the extreme and abnormal aspects of human relationships, including sexual ones, to shock or provoke their readers.
One reason could be that some fans want to explore different character dynamics. The original Bella - Edward relationship is so well - known and often idealized, so making Bella hate Edward creates a whole new set of tensions and story possibilities.
Perhaps there are some who have a darker side to their creativity and don't fully consider the implications of writing about abuse. But this kind of fanfiction should not be encouraged as it goes against the positive nature that most fanfiction communities strive for.
Some writers might create 'Edward is abusive to Bella' fanfiction to explore the darker side of human nature and relationships. They want to see how the story would unfold if the relationship had a negative turn.
One possible reason could be that Edward has some internal moral code. He might believe that acting on Bella's seduction goes against his principles, perhaps related to his view on relationships or self - control.
One reason could be for shock value. Writers might want to create something completely different from the normal, loving relationship in the Twilight series to get a strong reaction from readers. Another possibility is that they want to explore the darker sides of the characters, pushing the boundaries of what we know about Bella and Edward.
No. Fan - created content that involves promoting hate or negative and inappropriate themes like this is not acceptable. It goes against the positive spirit that fan - created works should have and can also be offensive to fans of the original Edward and Bella story.
One possible reason could be that Edward has some internal conflict. Maybe he has a strong sense of self - control and believes that getting involved with Bella in that way goes against his principles. He might be worried about the consequences it could have on Bella's life or his own existence as a vampire.
It could also be due to misunderstandings. Fanfiction often plays with the idea of miscommunication between them. Maybe Bella misinterprets Edward's over - protectiveness as a lack of trust in her ability to handle vampire - related situations. Or Edward might misunderstand Bella's need for independence as a sign that she doesn't love him as much as he thought. These misunderstandings can escalate into arguments.