The plot is crucial. A really good fanfiction will have an engaging and unique plot. It could be a 'what - if' scenario, like what if Voldemort had won the Battle of Hogwarts? Or it could be a story that fills in the gaps in the original series, like what happened during the summers at the Dursleys that we didn't see. Good world - building is also important. If it's set in a different part of the wizarding world, it needs to be described vividly so that readers can picture it.
The writing style matters a great deal. If the writing is engaging, with good grammar and a flow that makes it easy to read, it's more likely to be considered a great fanfiction. Also, a sense of authenticity to the original Harry Potter series helps. It should capture the magic, the humor, and the themes of friendship, love, and good versus evil that are so central to the books. For example, if it's a story about the Marauders' time at Hogwarts, it should feel like it could be part of the same universe as the original books in terms of the tone and the values it presents.
A great Harry Potter fanfiction often has well - developed characters. It takes the existing characters from the books and either expands on them in a believable way or creates interesting new ones that fit into the wizarding world. For example, if it's a story about Harry's post - Hogwarts life, it should stay true to his character traits like his bravery and loyalty.
A great new Harry Potter fanfiction often has a fresh take on the existing characters. For example, it might explore a different side of Hermione, like her life as a Muggle - born in a more in - depth way. The plot also needs to be engaging. It could be a new adventure that the trio goes on during their time at Hogwarts that we haven't seen in the original books. Good writing style is crucial too. If the author can create a vivid description of the wizarding world, it really draws the reader in.
Well, a 'Best Comedy' Harry Potter fanfiction often has a unique take on the source material. It might exaggerate certain aspects of the wizarding world for comical effect. For example, the strictness of Snape could be over - the - top, and the students' attempts to outwit him could be really funny. Another factor is the use of pop - culture references in a way that blends well with the Harry Potter universe. If the author can make a joke about a modern - day meme but in the context of Hogwarts, it can be quite hilarious. Also, the pacing is important. Quick - paced humor with a series of comical events one after another can keep the reader entertained. And if it can make fun of some of the clichés in the Harry Potter series in a light - hearted way, that's a plus too.
A good Harry Potter Quidditch fanfiction often has well - written action scenes. Since Quidditch is a fast - paced sport, the story should be able to convey that energy. For example, descriptions of the players zooming on their brooms, chasing the Snitch, and the intense rivalries between the teams.
In my opinion, the best Harry Potter fanfictions are those that manage to be both familiar and novel. They should feel like they belong to the Harry Potter universe, so using the existing locations like Diagon Alley and Hogwarts in a natural way is important. At the same time, they need to bring something new to the table. This could be a new character arc for an existing character or a new magical creature. The fanfiction also has to be well - paced. If it drags on too long in one part or rushes through important events, it won't be as good. And the emotional impact is crucial. A fanfiction that can make the reader feel the same range of emotions as the original books, from excitement during a Quidditch match to sadness at the loss of a character, is more likely to be considered among the best.
Well, a great 'Harry Potter' fanfiction often has well - developed characters. Just like in the original books, the characters need to feel real and have depth. For example, if it's a story about Draco Malfoy, it should show more than just his mean - spirited side from the books. It could explore his family pressures and his internal struggles. Another factor is a unique plot. It shouldn't just be a rehash of the original story but add something new. Maybe it's a different take on the Triwizard Tournament or a new mystery in Hogwarts. And of course, good writing quality. If the grammar and style are all over the place, it's hard to enjoy the story.
A great 'Harry Potter Master of Death' fanfiction often has a well - developed plot. It should expand on the concept of mastering death in a way that makes sense within the Harry Potter universe. For example, it could explore how Harry's new power affects his relationships with his friends like Ron and Hermione. Also, good character development is key. Harry should grow and change in a believable way as he grapples with his new status.
One thing that can make a Harry Potter femslash fanfiction the best is how it explores themes that were either hinted at or completely new in the context of the female - female relationships. For example, if it's a story about Ginny and Luna, it could explore themes of female empowerment and friendship evolving into something more. It should also have a good plot. A fic that just focuses on the romance without a proper story arc can get boring. So, a balance between relationship development and an interesting plot is key.
A great Harry Potter and Avengers fanfiction often has a seamless blend of the two universes. For example, it might find a way to incorporate Hogwarts into the Avengers' world or vice versa. This could involve having Avengers characters learn magic at Hogwarts or Harry Potter characters using their magic to help the Avengers in a battle.
A great plot is crucial. For example, if it has a unique take on time - travel like in some fanfics where Harry gets to meet Lily in a different time period. This adds an exciting element to the story.
Character development is key too. When characters from both series interact, it should feel natural. For instance, if Tony Stark were to meet Hermione Granger, their conversations should be engaging, with each character staying true to their original personalities. Stark might be impressed by Hermione's intelligence and magic, while Hermione could be intrigued by Stark's technological genius. Good crossovers also explore how the characters grow and change as a result of interacting with a completely different world and set of characters.