Is 'davemeltzerwon good story' a proper English phrase?

No. It doesn't seem to be a common phrase as it's rather unclear and not something that is widely known or used in general language.

No. It is not a proper English phrase. In standard English, we don't have such a construction that makes logical sense in the normal language use.

No. A proper English phrase should consist of appropriate words. 'Wife' is a regular term for a married woman and 'deal' can be a valid word in many contexts. But 'creampie' is a very inappropriate and vulgar term. So this 'wife deal creampie story' cannot be considered a proper English phrase.

Definitely not. It seems like a random or perhaps a very specialized or local usage that doesn't conform to normal English grammar and semantics. English has rules for combining words and phrases, and this doesn't follow them.

No. In standard English, this phrase is not proper. It has an unclear construction and 'go story' is not a valid collocation.

No, it's not a proper English phrase. In proper English, we don't use such combinations that seem both unclear and inappropriate in normal communication.

No. It's not a proper phrase. Firstly, 'dick' is a very vulgar term that is not suitable for formal or general use. Secondly, the whole combination of words is rather strange and doesn't convey a proper meaning that would be acceptable in normal English usage.

No. The word 'firsl' is misspelled. It should be 'first'. And even if it was spelled correctly, it's still a rather strange and ungrammatical phrase as it stands without further context to clarify its intended meaning.

No. In proper English, 'daddys' should be 'daddy's' and 'hurtd' is an incorrect spelling. So it is not a proper English phrase.

Definitely not. 'Asleep' is a normal English word, but 'day novel' is an unusual and ungrammatical combination. English phrases usually have a more logical and accepted structure, and this one clearly doesn't fit the bill.