How can one argue that 'Star Wars' isn't science fiction?

Star Wars has a lot of things that are just not scientifically possible. Like hyperspace travel being so easy and common. In real science fiction, there would be more focus on the scientific challenges of such travel. Also, the creatures in Star Wars are often just made - up for the sake of coolness, not based on any scientific understanding of evolution or biology. So, it's not really science fiction.

Well, some might say 'Star Wars' isn't pure science fiction because it has a lot of elements of fantasy. It has things like the Force, which is a rather mystical concept that doesn't really have a basis in scientific theory. It's more about a spiritual and magical power that certain characters can use, which is more in line with fantasy tropes.

Well, it could be that for some, the focus on characters and the story over hard science makes them question its status as pure sci-fi. But Star Wars definitely incorporates plenty of sci-fi concepts and settings.

One way to argue that 'Star Trek Discovery' is not science fiction is to look at its use of space and alien species. In true science fiction, these elements are often used to explore new ideas about evolution, intelligence, and the nature of the universe. If in 'Star Trek Discovery' the aliens are just there as set dressing for the human - centered drama and the space settings are not used to really dig into scientific concepts like relativity or the search for extraterrestrial life, then it may not be science fiction.

The reason Star Wars might not be pure science fiction is that it emphasizes spectacle and heroic tales over detailed scientific explanations and predictions. Plus, the fantastical aspects like the Force and alien species with undefined origins set it apart from the core of science fiction.

Think about the technology in 'Star Wars'. While it seems advanced, it's not really based on scientific principles. For instance, the Death Star. It's a huge, planet - destroying weapon, but there's no real scientific theory behind how it could be built or function. It's more of a plot - driving, fantastical device, which is a sign that 'Star Wars' is more of a space adventure or space fantasy rather than science fiction.

Simple. Look at the Force. It has no scientific explanation, so it's more like magic. That's fantasy.

Star Wars is classified as science fiction for several reasons. Firstly, it has spaceships that can zip through galaxies at warp speed. Secondly, it showcases unique alien races and planets with their own cultures and ecosystems. And let's not forget about the use of advanced weapons and force powers that are beyond our current understanding.

Maybe it has some licensing or distribution issues that prevent it from being on Disney. Could be related to rights or contractual stuff.

Star Wars is a blend of both science fiction and science fantasy. It has elements of advanced technology and space exploration that are typical of science fiction, but also magical and mythical elements that lean towards science fantasy.