In the fanfiction, why doesn't Harry trust Dumbledore?

In some fanfiction, Harry might not trust Dumbledore because the author wants to explore different power dynamics. Maybe they show Dumbledore keeping too many secrets, like about Harry's past or the true nature of the threats he faces. This secrecy can make Harry feel manipulated and thus lead to a lack of trust.

One possible reason could be that Harry discovers some hidden actions of Dumbledore that seem manipulative. For example, if Dumbledore has been keeping secrets about Harry's past or his destiny without fully explaining them. Harry might feel used or deceived, leading to his distrust.

In some fanfictions, the author might want to create a new plot twist. Maybe they introduce a misunderstanding, like Hermione accidentally getting involved in something that looks suspicious to Harry. For example, if she's caught in a secret meeting that she can't immediately explain, Harry could start to lose trust.

Maybe in the fanfiction, Harry has had bad experiences with adults. For example, some adults in the story might have betrayed his trust in the past, so he becomes wary of all adults.

Maybe he has read some really bad Order fanfictions before that were full of inaccuracies or out - of - character portrayals, which made him lose trust in this type of fanfiction.

Maybe in some fanfictions, Dumbledore's character is portrayed in a way that Harry doesn't like. For example, if the author makes Dumbledore overly controlling or having some hidden motives that are against Harry's interests.

It could be that in the fanfiction, a dark wizard has somehow influenced the Weasleys' actions without their knowledge. Harry, being cautious after all his experiences with the dark side, might misinterpret these changes in their behavior as signs of untrustworthiness. So he doesn't trust them until he figures out what's really going on.

Harry Potter has lived through his own real experiences in the wizarding world. Fanfiction is often just the creative interpretations of fans. It could distort the true nature of his relationships, the events he's been through, and the values of the wizarding world. So, he doesn't blindly trust it. For example, some fanfiction might change the way his friendships are portrayed, which doesn't align with his real experiences.

Maybe he has been betrayed too many times in the past. For example, in the original story, some so - called friends or allies might have let him down, and this experience makes him overly cautious in the fanfiction.

In the fanfiction, the plot might develop with Hermione secretly investigating Dumbledore. She could enlist the help of other characters who also have doubts. As she uncovers more secrets, her distrust grows, and this causes a rift within the group of friends. Some might side with her, while others still believe in Dumbledore. This creates a lot of tension and conflict as they try to deal with the threat of the dark side while also dealing with their internal differences.