Well, often it's the unexpected elements. Maybe a strange noise in an otherwise quiet Sunday morning. Or perhaps a mysterious figure that appears out of nowhere while the world is supposed to be peaceful. It could also be the contrast between the normalcy of a Sunday morning and the sudden intrusion of something scary that makes it so frightening.
In a one Sunday morning scary story, what makes it truly scary is the sense of vulnerability. People usually feel safe on a Sunday morning. But if there's a scary story set during this time, it might involve things like a home invasion where the family thought they were secure. The disruption of this peaceful time creates a deep sense of fear. For example, the story could start with a family having breakfast and then suddenly hearing a strange knock on the door, and when they open it, there's no one there, but then strange things start to happen inside the house, like objects moving on their own.
One classic Sunday morning scary story could be about an old abandoned house on the edge of town. People say that on Sunday mornings, if you pass by it, you can hear strange hymn - like singing coming from inside. But when you look in the windows, there's no one there. It's as if the ghosts of the former residents are still having their Sunday service.
One example could be a story where a man wakes up on a Sunday morning and goes for a walk in the park. As he's walking, he notices a strange mist that seems to be following him. Every time he tries to get away from it, it gets closer. He starts to run, but the mist engulfs him, and suddenly he finds himself in a different place, like a dark forest. He hears strange howls and sees eyes peering at him from the bushes.
The unknown. In a scary story, not knowing what's going to happen next or what the strange thing really is makes it scary. For instance, if there's a noise in the attic, but you don't know if it's a ghost or just a rat, the mystery creates fear.
Sunday is often associated with peace and rest in many cultures. So, perhaps people don't like to think of scary things on a day that's typically set aside for relaxation and religious activities. It goes against the general mood of the day.
The unknown aspect makes bong scary stories frightening. We don't know what might happen when the bong is involved in the story. It could be that the bong has some sort of supernatural power.
The mystery behind the keyhole. You can't see the whole picture, just a small part through it. It's like a tease of the horror that might be on the other side.
The atmosphere plays a huge role. If a story is set in a spooky place like an old, abandoned house or a dark forest, it immediately gives off a feeling of dread. Also, when the characters in the story are helpless against the ghost, it adds to the fear. It makes the reader or listener feel like they could be in the same situation and be powerless too. In addition, unexpected events like sudden noises or apparitions popping up out of nowhere can startle and terrify.
The darkness in the cave makes it scary. It hides all kinds of potential threats.
The unknown elements in 'the wreck scary story' can be really scary. For example, if it's a shipwreck, not knowing what lurks in the dark, flooded cabins can send shivers down your spine.
The mystery behind what's on the other side of the keyhole can be very frightening. You can't see the whole picture, just a limited view, which makes your imagination run wild.