What are the possible reasons for Natsu being written as abusive to Lucy in fanfiction?

Well, it depends on the specific fanfiction. There are thousands of fanfictions out there, and some might misinterpret or twist the characters' personalities. Natsu is generally seen as a passionate and sometimes hot - headed character in the original, not an abusive one. However, in certain fan - made stories that aim for a more 'dramatic' or 'dark' take, they could write him as being abusive to Lucy. But these are not in line with the general perception of the characters.

One reason could be that the fanfic focuses on a different pairing for Lucy. So, to make that other relationship more plausible, the author made Lucy not have feelings for Natsu.

Perhaps Natsu is under the influence of a powerful and dark magic that makes him lose control of himself and accidentally hurt Lucy. It could also be that Natsu is trying to protect Lucy from something but his actions end up causing her harm instead. Like if he tries to keep her away from a dangerous situation by pushing her too hard and she gets injured.

One possible reason could be to seek new adventures. They might feel they've reached a point in Fairy Tail where they've done all they can and want to explore new magic and challenges elsewhere. For example, they could have heard of a far - off land with a different type of magic that they are eager to learn about.

Perhaps the author wants to introduce a sense of mystery. Natsu's secret royalty could be part of a larger mystery in the fanfiction. It could be related to his past, like he was separated from his royal family as a baby for some unknown reason. Another reason might be to explore different power structures. As royalty, Natsu would have different kinds of power and influence compared to just being a dragon slayer in Fairy Tail.

Well, in some fanfictions, it could be that Lucy is under a curse. This curse makes her act out of character and she ends up hurting Natsu. Maybe she is cursed to attack the closest person to her, and at that moment, it's Natsu. Or it could be a situation where Lucy is forced to choose between saving herself and Natsu in a dangerous situation, and her choice, even if it's to save herself, could be seen as hurting Natsu. Also, there could be a plot where Lucy is brainwashed by an enemy who wants to break the bond between her and Natsu, and as a result, she causes him harm.

One possible reason could be that Lucy is too focused on her own goals, like becoming a stronger mage or achieving something specific in the guild. She might see a romantic relationship as a distraction at that moment.

Stress can be a big factor. Maybe she has financial problems, like she can't pay the bills or is worried about losing her job. This stress can make her lash out at her family.

Well, there are several potential plots for this kind of fanfiction. Maybe Natsu is in an environment where he is constantly bullied and abused, like in a guild where some members are jealous of his power. Lucy, who has a kind heart, decides to take him under her wing. She might teach him self - defense or help him build his self - esteem. Another plot could involve Natsu being abused due to a family secret or a prophecy that makes others target him. Lucy, with her intelligence and courage, tries to rewrite the fate that seems to doom Natsu to abuse. This could involve going on quests to find artifacts or information that can change the situation.

Some writers might create 'Edward is abusive to Bella' fanfiction to explore the darker side of human nature and relationships. They want to see how the story would unfold if the relationship had a negative turn.