One idea could be exploring a new power that the third devil discovers. For example, a unique ability to manipulate time on a small scale during battles, which would add a whole new dimension to the fight scenes. Another idea is to focus on the third devil's relationships with other characters in a different way. Maybe the third devil forms an unexpected alliance with a group that was previously an enemy, leading to some really interesting character development and plot twists.
A great idea is to put the third devil in a completely different setting. Instead of the usual Highschool DxD world, send them to a parallel dimension where the rules are different. They might have to adapt to new powers, new enemies, and new allies. This would allow for a fresh take on the character and would keep readers interested as they see how the third devil copes with these new challenges.
One idea could be a new devil character arriving at Kuoh Academy with a unique power that challenges the existing power dynamics among the devils there. For example, a devil who can manipulate time in small increments during battles, which would make for some really intense and strategic fight scenes.
One idea could be a story where the main character, a human, discovers a unique power that allows them to hold their own against devils in the 'Highschool DxD' universe. They use this power to protect their school from devil threats that the regular characters might not be able to handle easily.
One idea could be an OC Devil who has a unique power related to time manipulation. For example, they can freeze time briefly in battles, giving them an edge. Another could be an OC Devil from a long - lost noble family trying to reclaim their family's honor and status within the Devil society. They would have to face many challenges and rivalries along the way.
One interesting plot idea could be a new character introduced in the fanfiction who has a unique power that disrupts the power balance in the High School DxD world. For example, a devil with the ability to nullify all other devil powers temporarily. This could lead to a lot of interesting conflicts and alliances as different factions try to either use or get rid of this new character.
One idea could be to focus on the characters' relationships outside of the main plot. For example, how the students interact during normal school days, like study groups or after - school clubs. Another idea is to create an alternate universe where the rules of the dxd world are slightly different in the high school setting, which could lead to new adventures and challenges for the characters.
Obviously, the third devil would be a main character. But also, characters like Issei could still play a major role. They might interact with the third devil in various ways, such as training together or getting into conflicts. Another potential main character could be a new character that you introduce specifically for this fanfiction. Maybe a mysterious transfer student who has some connection to the third devil's past or powers.
One idea could be a story where the characters from High School DxD are reimagined as toddlers, and their innocent interactions lead to comical and heartwarming situations. For example, Issei might be chasing after a butterfly instead of chasing girls in his usual way.
A third idea could be a fanfiction where Gaara becomes a devil himself. He could bring his ninja skills and his sand abilities into the devil society. This would change the power dynamics in the DxD highschool as he would be a very different type of devil compared to the existing ones, with his own moral code and way of doing things.
One idea could be to create an alternate universe where the main character has a different set of powers. For example, instead of the traditional Sacred Gear, they could have a power related to time manipulation. This would change the dynamics of battles and interactions with other characters.
A third idea could be a time - travel fanfiction. For example, a character from Highschool DxD travels back in time to the era of Bleach and meets Ichigo when he was still developing his powers. This could lead to some interesting interactions and changes in the timeline of both universes.