In some 'always getting over you vampire diaries fanfiction', the character decides to focus on their career or studies to get over the vampire. They become really involved in the local council's affairs in Mystic Falls or start learning about ancient vampire lore to distract themselves. Along the way, they might accidentally uncover secrets that either draw them closer to or further from the vampire they're trying to forget.
There might be a fanfiction where the character uses magic to erase their memories of the vampire they're getting over. But as they start to build a new life, things keep triggering small memories, and they have to fight to stay away from the vampire. It could be a story full of suspense and internal struggle as they battle their own heart and the pull of the vampire world.
Sometimes it's a vampire themselves trying to get over another vampire. Maybe a young vampire who was turned by a more powerful one and had feelings for them, but then realizes they need to break free. They could be struggling with their loyalty to their sire and their own desire for independence and a new life without that emotional attachment.
In some fanfiction, there could be a storyline where the characters are forced to work together on a community project. They initially resist but as they spend more time together, old feelings resurface. This creates a lot of tension and drama as they struggle between their past and present emotions. It's a great way to explore the characters' growth and their relationship in a new light.
One interesting Vampire Diaries fanfiction could be about an alternate universe where Elena is a vampire from the start. It changes the whole dynamic of her relationships. Another might focus on Damon and Bonnie's friendship, exploring how they could team up in different ways than in the show.
A really cool Vampire Diaries fanfiction story could be one where the Salvatores and the Mikaelsons team up against a greater evil. This would be a great way to see different characters with their own motives working together. There are also fanfictions that focus on the human side of things more. For instance, a story about Matt's life and how he copes with all the supernatural chaos around him, and how he might even find a way to fight back using his own human strengths.
One interesting story could be about Jeremy exploring his new vampire powers in a way that the show didn't fully explore. For example, he might use his vampire abilities to protect the town from a new threat that's not related to the typical vampires or werewolves. Maybe he teams up with some unexpected characters to fight this new danger.
One possible plotline could be that Damon is tortured by a powerful witch as revenge for something he did in the past. Maybe he accidentally killed a member of the witch's coven. Another could be that he is tortured by a group of vampires who want to send a message to Stefan. They might use vervain and sunlight to torture him in creative ways.
One interesting fanfiction could be a crossover where a character from The Vampire Diaries ends up in the world of Aquaman. For example, Elena could find herself in Atlantis and have to deal with the underwater politics and powers there while also trying to find a way back home. Another could be where a mermaid from Aquaman's world is turned into a vampire in a strange magical accident and has to adapt to both her new vampiric nature and her old mermaid ways.
Some Vampire Diaries CYOA fanfictions revolve around alternate universes. In one such story, the Salvatore brothers might be human, and they have to deal with the supernatural elements in a completely different way. The fanfiction could show how they adapt to having friends who are vampires and witches without having the same powers themselves. It would be interesting to see how they handle situations like the Originals coming to town without their vampire strength.
One interesting Vampire Diaries Mafia fanfiction could be 'The Dark Underworld of Mystic Falls'. It might explore how the vampire and werewolf clans interact with the mafia elements in the town. Another could be 'Mafia Alliances in Mystic Falls' which delves into the power struggles between different factions including the mafia and the supernatural beings. There are also ones that focus on a particular character like Damon getting involved with the mafia to protect Elena in a fanfic called 'Damon and the Mafia's Deal'.
Some fanfictions might delve into the magic systems in these shows. In a 'Originals Vampire Diaries' fanfiction, the author could expand on the use of different spells and how they affect vampires. They could create new spells or explore the limits of existing ones, adding more depth to the magical aspect of the story.