It could be an exploration of different character interpretations. Some fans might see Annabeth as having flaws that could potentially harm Percy. By writing these fanfictions, they can express their views on how the characters might react in certain situations that lead to Annabeth hurting Percy. It also gives a chance to explore different plotlines that deviate from the usual positive relationship between them.
One popular 'Annabeth hurts Percy' fanfiction might be 'Broken Trust'. In it, Annabeth's actions due to a misunderstanding cause Percy great emotional pain. Another could be 'Fractured Bond' where Annabeth's ambition leads her to make decisions that wound Percy deeply. There's also 'Shattered Heart' which shows how Annabeth's words can cut Percy like a knife.
Some writers make them royalty because it gives a sense of grandeur and importance. Percy and Annabeth are already popular characters, and by making them royalty, it elevates their status even more. It can also attract more readers who are interested in royalty - themed stories. The contrast between their demigod abilities and their royal duties creates a unique and engaging narrative. For instance, they might use their powers to defend their kingdoms from mythological threats in ways that normal royalty couldn't.
The popularity also lies in the fact that it adds a new layer to the characters. Percy showing his possessiveness and love in this way makes him more complex. And for Annabeth, it shows how she is valued by Percy. These fanfictions often explore the emotions and reactions of other characters too, which makes it interesting for readers.
These fanfictions are popular because they allow fans to explore different situations and scenarios that might not be in the original books. For example, the rescue could happen in a more dangerous or unexpected setting. Also, it gives a chance to develop the characters further. We can see more of Percy's determination and Annabeth's vulnerability in these stories, which adds depth to their relationship.
He could become withdrawn. Percy is a sensitive person at heart. So if Annabeth's actions are really hurtful, like if she cheats on him in a fanfic (although it's a very sad scenario), he would likely isolate himself from her and their friends. He might go off on his own to think things through and deal with his pain privately.
One example could be a story where Annabeth makes a thoughtless comment that deeply wounds Percy's self - esteem. For instance, she might compare him unfavorably to another demigod in terms of battle skills in front of their peers. This could lead to Percy feeling inadequate and hurt.
He could become withdrawn. Percy might start to distance himself from Annabeth, not wanting to be around her if she's going to be cruel. He might go off on his own and think about what she said, trying to figure out if he did something wrong.
In addition, fans are often very invested in the emotional arcs of the characters. The idea of Chloe hurting Beca can create a lot of drama and tension, which are elements that make for engaging stories. Fanfiction allows fans to take these characters and put them in situations that might not be explored in the original source material, and the 'Chloe Hurts Beca' concept is one such area that can lead to some really interesting and emotional tales.
Well, it's mainly because fans love Percy and Annabeth's relationship. The idea of a truth or dare situation leading to a kiss adds an element of fun and spontaneity to their relationship, which is really appealing.
One possible reason could be miscommunication. Maybe Annabeth said something without realizing how it would come across to Percy. For example, if she was stressed about a quest and snapped at him when he was just trying to be helpful.