Well, there's a campfire story about a haunted campsite. People say that if you set up your tent on a certain spot in the woods, at night you'll hear strange noises like growls and whispers. And then there's the story of the ghostly hiker. A hiker disappeared in the mountains long ago, and now if you hike the same trail at night, you might see his apparition. Also, the story of the cursed campsite where a group of people died mysteriously, and now it's said that any who stay there will be haunted by their spirits.
A really terrifying campfire story is the one about the werewolf in the forest. In a small village near the woods, every full moon, a werewolf would come out and attack the villagers. One night, a group of brave young men went into the forest to hunt it, but they never came back. Another story is about the mermaid that lures fishermen to their deaths. She sings a beautiful song near the shore, and when the fishermen get close, she drags them underwater. And then there's the story of the creepy old house in the middle of the forest. Anyone who enters it at night never comes out alive.
The unknown is a very terrifying element. For example, in stories where there are strange noises in the dark woods. You don't know what's making those noises, whether it's a wild animal or something more sinister. Another terrifying element is the isolation. When the characters are alone in the middle of the forest, far from any help, it makes the situation scarier. Just like in the story where the hiker was lost and had no one to turn to.
A really scary one is about the lost scout. In the mountains, there was a young scout who got separated from his troop during a storm. He was never found alive. Ever since then, during bad weather, scouts on the mountain can hear his cries for help. They sometimes see a figure that looks like him running through the trees, as if still lost and desperate to find his way back to safety. This story is so scary because it makes you think about how easily it could happen to you. There's also the mystery and the feeling of helplessness in the face of the unknown that adds to the terror.
The unknown is a really terrifying element. For example, in many stories, there are strange noises in the dark that you can't identify. It could be a wild animal, but your mind imagines all sorts of supernatural things. Another is isolation. When the characters are alone in a spooky place like an old cabin in the woods or an abandoned building, it makes the situation scarier because there's no one to turn to for help.
Scary horror campfire stories are terrifying because of their ability to tap into our primal fears. Fear of the dark is a common one, and these stories often use the cover of darkness to hide the unknown threats. The idea of something being out there, watching us, but we can't see it clearly. Another element is the violation of the normal. For instance, seeing a figure that defies the laws of nature, like a person walking through walls in a haunted house story. The anticipation and build - up are also important. A story that slowly builds the tension, like the girl waiting for the water - logged figure to reach her, keeps us on the edge of our seats and makes the final scare even more effective.
Use a spooky voice. Changing your tone to be low and menacing can really draw people in. For example, when you tell about the approaching monster, make your voice hushed and full of dread.
One classic is 'The Hook'. A couple is parked at a lovers' lane. They hear on the radio about an escaped lunatic with a hook for a hand. Strange noises start coming from outside the car. In the end, they speed away and when they get home, they find a bloody hook hanging on the car door handle.
The story of 'The Babysitter and the Man Upstairs' is quite terrifying. A babysitter is taking care of a child at night. She keeps getting strange phone calls from someone asking if she's checked on the children. Then she realizes there's someone upstairs in the house. She tries to call the police, but the phone lines are cut. It creates a lot of suspense as she has to protect the child while being in a really scary situation.
One not scary campfire story could be about a friendly little gnome who lives in a garden. He helps the flowers grow by singing to them every morning. The animals in the garden love him and they all have little adventures together, like looking for the lost acorn or building a tiny bridge over a puddle.
The story of 'The Headless Horseman' is also great. It's set in a small town where a horseman without a head rides around at night. It's a classic that has been told for generations around campfires. The mystery and the element of fear make it really engaging.
One interesting campfire story could be about a haunted forest. Legend has it that at midnight, a white figure roams the forest paths. It was once a lost hiker who never found their way out and now their spirit lingers. Another could be the story of a friendly forest gnome who helps lost travelers find their way home by leaving little shiny pebbles as a guide. And then there's the story of a magical tree in the forest that grants wishes to those who are pure of heart but only on a full moon night.