I'm not sure which specific fanfiction this refers to exactly. However, this kind of plot in fanfiction often involves a dark and disturbing scenario where Hermione is put in a very difficult and forced situation by a Death Eater. It could be used to explore themes of power, resistance, and the dark side of the wizarding world. But it's important to note that such fanfictions might not be suitable for all readers as they can be quite intense.
In some fanfictions with this kind of plot, the author might be trying to show Hermione's strength even in the face of such a horrible situation. She could be depicted as using her intelligence to try and outwit the Death Eater. For example, she might pretend to cooperate while secretly planning an escape or a way to undermine the Death Eater's plans. But again, this is all in the realm of fan - created stories and not part of the official 'Harry Potter' canon.
Fanfictions with this theme can be controversial. On one hand, they can offer a new perspective on the characters and the 'Harry Potter' universe. On the other hand, they might cross a line for some readers because of the nature of the situation Hermione is put in. Some readers might be interested in seeing how the author resolves the situation, whether it's through Hermione's own agency or with the help of other characters like Harry or Ron coming to her rescue.
This is a complex question. In the context of fanfiction, it depends on how it's written. If it's written in a way that glorifies the actions of the Death Eater or is overly exploitative of Hermione's situation, then it's probably not ethical. However, if it's used as a means to explore deeper themes like the fight against evil and Hermione's resilience, it could be considered more acceptable.
Over time, if she couldn't immediately escape, Hermione would try to influence the Death Eater. She would use her knowledge and strong moral compass to show him the error of his ways. She might start by having debates with him about the Dark Arts and the ideology of the Death Eaters, hoping to make him see the light.
One popular fanfiction in this theme might be 'The Darkest Path'. In it, the author creates a tense situation where Hermione is forced to deal with the Death Eaters' schemes in a very immersive way. Another could be 'Forced Alliance' which shows Hermione having to form an uneasy alliance with a Death Eater under duress.
Bellatrix Lestrange is also a likely candidate. Her encounter with Hermione would be extremely intense. Given her loyalty to Voldemort and her rather unhinged nature, she would likely pose a serious threat to Hermione, but Hermione might also find a way to use Bellatrix's madness against her.
Another aspect could be an unexpected bond forming between Hermione and the Death Eater. As they are forced to spend time together, they might start to understand each other on a deeper level. This could lead to a moral dilemma for the Death Eater, especially if he starts to develop feelings for Hermione. He would then have to choose between his loyalty to the Death Eaters and his new - found connection with her.
In this type of fanfiction, the relationship between Hermione and the Death Eater could be very complex. Maybe it starts as a hostile one, but as the story progresses, they might find some common ground or mutual understanding. It could also be a story of redemption for the Death Eater through Hermione's influence.
Bellatrix Lestrange's younger brother or some other minor Death Eater character could be used. This would allow for the creation of a new character with his own motives and backstory. He could be betrothed to Hermione as part of a larger plot by Voldemort to gain control over Hermione's knowledge and magic. This would put Hermione in a very difficult position as she would be tied to a very dark and dangerous family.
There's also a possibility that it could be a minor Death Eater that we don't know much about from the original series. The author of the fanfiction could create a new character who was a Death Eater but is now having doubts. Hermione could be the one to find this person and start their journey of change. This would give the author a lot of creative freedom to develop the character's backstory and their relationship with Hermione.
Another idea could be that she is somehow brainwashed. There could be a dark spell or a powerful magical object that alters her perception and makes her believe in the Death Eater ideology. In this scenario, her friends would have to find a way to break the spell and bring her back to her true self.
One possible aspect of this fanfiction could be Hermione's encounter with an unexpected Death Eater. Maybe she stumbles upon one during a mission or while exploring a hidden area. This encounter could lead to a series of thrilling events, like a battle of wits or a dangerous duel.