Reddit Gaming Horror Stories: What are some of the scariest ones?

The scariest for me was a story about a family who bought an antique mirror. After they brought it home, they started seeing distorted faces in it at night. One of the kids even said the face in the mirror talked to him, saying creepy things like 'join me on the other side'. They got rid of the mirror but strange things continued to happen in their house for a while.

I once read a Reddit horror story about a family who bought an old house. They discovered a locked room in the basement. When they finally managed to open it, they found a bunch of old portraits, and in each portrait, the eyes seemed to follow them. Then, at night, they would hear voices coming from the basement, as if the people in the portraits were talking. It was so spooky that they sold the house soon after.

One Reddit user shared a story about a furry - themed role - playing game that took a dark turn. The players were supposed to be in a friendly, fictional world, but one player started to use the game as an outlet for their real - life aggression. They started attacking other players' characters in really violent and sexual ways. The moderators had a hard time dealing with it, and it left a lot of the players feeling violated and horrified.

One of the scariest true supernatural horror stories is the Bell Witch Haunting. It involves a spirit that tormented the Bell family in Tennessee. There were strange noises, physical attacks on family members, and the spirit even communicated with them, predicting deaths. It was so terrifying that it became a well - known legend in American folklore.

One of the scariest might be the ones where there's an unexpected twist with the mother figure. For example, she could seem normal at first but then turn out to be a malevolent entity. Maybe she starts to have strange behavior like whispering in a language no one understands or having a creepy stare that just makes you feel uneasy.

A group of hikers once went into an uncharted area. They found an old, abandoned cabin. When they entered, they noticed some really strange symbols on the walls. As they were exploring, they heard a loud bang outside. One of them went to check and saw a figure in the distance. They all quickly left the cabin, fearing it was some sort of deranged hermit or something more sinister.

One of the scariest true Christmas horror stories is about a family who found a strange old ornament in their attic. When they hung it on the tree, that night they heard eerie whispering. Turns out, the ornament was from a long - ago Christmas when a tragic event occurred in the house. Another story is of a man who received a Christmas present that was a doll with a really creepy face. Every night, the doll seemed to move on its own.

One really scary Tagalog true horror story is about the 'White Lady' often seen on dark roads. People claim to see a woman in a white dress, her face pale and sad. It's said she was a victim of a tragic accident and now haunts the place where she died. Another one involves an old abandoned house where strange noises and apparitions have been reported by those who dared to enter.

One really scary 'Dr No Sleep Horror Story' is about a haunted hospital. A patient wakes up in the middle of the night to find strange shadows moving across the walls. The lights start flickering, and she hears eerie whispers. Turns out the hospital was built on an old burial ground, and the spirits are restless.

One Reddit horror story I read was about a person who moved into an old house. Strange noises started at night, like scratching on the walls. They initially thought it was rodents, but then they found deep claw marks that seemed too large for any normal animal. Every night, the noises got louder and more terrifying. Eventually, they moved out in a hurry.