What makes '1984' a Fiction rather than Nonfiction?

The characters are fictional. There are no real Ponyboy or Johnny in real life. That's a big sign it's fiction.

The presence of supernatural elements makes mythology seem like fiction. Gods flying, people turning into animals, and magic are not things we observe in real life. It's hard to classify such stories as nonfiction when they are so far from our known reality.

The fact that it's based on a real murder case. Capote did extensive research, interviewed people involved, and presented real events.

The fact that the events in 'Charlotte's Web' are highly improbable in the real world indicates it's fiction. For example, a spider writing words in her web to save a pig is not something that would happen in non - fictional circumstances. Also, the animals in the story having complex emotions and relationships like humans is a fictional element. Real - life animals don't experience these things in the same way as the characters in the book.

The Great Gatsby is clearly fiction. One major aspect is the highly stylized and exaggerated portrayal of the Jazz Age. The extreme wealth, the lavish lifestyles, and the moral decay depicted are more in the realm of fictional exploration. Fitzgerald uses these fictional elements to comment on the real - world ideas of the American Dream, class differences, and love. The characters' relationships are also too complex and idealized to be nonfiction. For instance, Gatsby's unwavering love for Daisy, which is almost obsessive, is a fictional device to drive the story forward. The story's setting, while based on real - life Long Island, is fictionalized to fit the needs of the narrative. The parties, the mansions, and the social hierarchies are all part of Fitzgerald's fictional world - building.

It seems nonfiction because it details the real - life challenges that Salva Dut faced. The descriptions of the environment, the lack of water, and the perils of war are all based on real situations in Sudan. For instance, the long distances he had to walk to find water are real problems that people in that area deal with. So, it's not a made - up fictional story but a portrayal of a real struggle.

It's clearly fiction because it has elements that are too stylized for non - fiction. The dialogue, for instance, is often crafted in a way that's more about creating drama and character development than reporting real conversations. Also, the story arc of the band's rise and fall is a common fictional trope in music - related stories, and in this case, it's not based on a real - life band's actual history.

For me, writing fiction gives you the freedom to create entire worlds and characters from scratch. You can let your imagination run wild and tell stories that might not exist in the real world. Nonfiction is often constrained by facts and reality.

It's considered fiction because the characters and the specific events are created by the author. For example, the Logan family is a fictional family that the author uses to represent the experiences of African - Americans. If it were nonfiction, it would be based on real people and real events without the fictional elements of character creation and plot construction.

The characters are fictional. There's no evidence that these exact people existed in real life. So, it's fiction.