What are the possible reasons why someone would create a 'Harry Potter abused sister' oc fanfic?

Some people might create it just for shock value. They want to create something so out - of - the - ordinary and gross that it grabs attention, even if it's in a negative way.

In fanfiction, while creativity is encouraged, there are boundaries. The idea of abuse in the context of Harry Potter is not only unethical but also not in line with the overall tone and world - building of the series. The series promotes things like loyalty, bravery, and kindness. A theme of abuse would be a dark stain on this otherwise positive and magical world. It could also lead to discomfort and negative reactions from the majority of the fan community who cherish the positive aspects of the Harry Potter universe.

Some people might write it for shock value. They want to create something that is completely unexpected and out - of - the - box, even if it's inappropriate. It could also be a very misinterpreted exploration of the characters' relationships, where the writer has a warped view of the family dynamics in the 'Harry Potter' world.

It could also be very distressing for younger fans who look up to the Harry Potter series. They might be exposed to this inappropriate content and be confused or traumatized by it. Additionally, it could lead to a split in the fan community, with some fans being outraged by the existence of such a fanfic and others perhaps trying to defend the idea of 'creativity' even when it crosses ethical boundaries.

There are many fanfics out there, but the idea of 'Harry Potter abused sister' is a very dark and untrue to the original spirit of the series. Most official and well - regarded fanfic communities would not support such a disturbing concept. It's also important to note that any form of abuse is unacceptable in literature, especially when it involves characters from a family - friendly franchise like Harry Potter.

Perhaps they have a distorted view of creativity. They think that by adding such extreme and inappropriate elements, they are being unique. However, they fail to realize that it not only goes against the values of the Harry Potter series but also has a negative impact on the fans and the overall perception of the story.

Some people might write it for shock value. They want to create something that is so out - of - the - box and unexpected that it grabs people's attention. It could also be a way for them to explore very extreme and dark 'what - if' scenarios in the Harry Potter universe, even if it goes against the original story's essence.

Well, it might be because some fans feel that Slytherin has been somewhat demonized in the original books. So, they create fanfiction where Slytherin is the victim of abuse, perhaps as a way to give the house more depth and sympathy. Also, the idea of abuse can create a lot of drama and conflict, which are elements that make a story interesting. Fanfiction writers might be using this concept to attract readers who are interested in more complex and edgy storylines. Additionally, it could be a form of exploring the morality and ethics within the Harry Potter universe in a very extreme way.

There should not be any such fanfic. The Harry Potter series is about friendship, courage and magic, not about abuse. This kind of concept goes against the positive values that the original work promotes. It is also unethical and can be very disturbing to the fans who love the original story.

Another aspect is quality control. A lot of fanfic varies greatly in terms of writing quality. Some people might have had bad experiences with poorly written Harry Potter fanfic in the past and thus choose to say no to all of it. They don't want to waste their time sifting through sub - par stories when they can just re - read the original, well - crafted novels.