To refute it, we need to consider the fact that Harry Potter has its own independent mythology. It has different races like wizards, muggles, and magical creatures. There are no elements from the story of Jesus. It has its own set of values like loyalty, bravery which are not related to religious fanfiction about Jesus.
By simply looking at the facts. 'Harry Potter' was published years before SCP even existed. So it can't be a fanfiction of something that didn't exist yet.
It can be refuted by looking at the origin. Harry Potter was created by J.K. Rowling's imagination. There's no basis in Greek primordial elements for the core concepts of Hogwarts, the sorting hat, or the magic wands. It's a completely different fictional universe.
To support it, one can look at the overarching themes. The fight against Voldemort has an aspect of a resistance movement, much like the resistance against the Nazis. The Death Eaters' discriminatory views mirror the bigotry of the Nazis. However, to refute it, consider that 'Harry Potter' is set in a magical world with things like magic wands, potions, and magical creatures that have no relation to WW2.
It might combine them by imagining Jesus as a hidden figure in the wizarding history. He could have influenced some of the early magic or the creation of certain magical artifacts. So, it's like a backstory that ties the two concepts together. In this kind of fanfiction, there could be references to ancient spells that were actually based on Jesus' words or actions, which would be a really interesting blend of the two worlds.
The unique aspect might also lie in the moral and ethical exploration. The Harry Potter series already has a strong moral undertone, with good vs. evil being a central theme. By bringing in elements related to Jesus, such as his teachings on forgiveness and love, fanfiction can further deepen this exploration. For example, a story could show how characters who were once on the wrong side are redeemed through the influence of Jesus - like teachings, which could add a new layer of complexity to the characters' development and the overall plot of the fanfiction.
The idea of sacrifice is also common. Harry is constantly sacrificing himself for the greater good, like when he goes to face Voldemort in the final battle. Jesus' sacrifice is well - known in religious stories. Fanfictions could explore how the two types of sacrifice are related, perhaps by having Harry's sacrifices be seen in a more religious light or vice - versa. Another theme could be the fight against evil. Both Jesus and Harry Potter are in a sense battling against forces of evil. Fanfictions may depict how their different approaches to fighting evil could be combined or contrasted.
One popular type of Jesus and Harry Potter fanfiction might involve exploring the themes of sacrifice and redemption in the context of the magical world of Harry Potter. For example, some fanfictions could draw parallels between Jesus' self - sacrifice and the sacrifices made by characters in Harry Potter, like Harry's willingness to face Voldemort to save his friends and the wizarding world.
There are some interesting Jesus and Harry Potter fanfictions out there. One I've heard of combines the themes of sacrifice from the story of Jesus with the self - sacrificing acts we often see in the Harry Potter series. It might be a bit hard to find, but exploring fanfiction websites like Archive of Our Own could lead you to some great reads.
It's a completely wrong statement. Harry Potter was created by J.K. Rowling as a story about a young wizard's journey in a magical world. It doesn't have any elements of being Jesus fanfiction. There are no religious overtones in the main plot related to Jesus. The story is centered around Hogwarts, magic spells, and the fight against Voldemort. It's just a wild and inappropriate comparison.
One interesting 'Harry Potter Jesus fanfiction' could be a story where the values of Jesus, like love and forgiveness, are incorporated into the magical world of Harry Potter. For example, Harry might learn a new kind of magic based on the self - sacrificing love that Jesus represents. It could be a unique take on how the wizarding world could be influenced by such powerful spiritual concepts.