Build up the suspense. Don't reveal the scary part right away. Describe the setting, the characters' feelings, and slowly introduce the element of fear. For instance, start by talking about how peaceful the forest seems at first, then gradually introduce the strange noises and the sense of unease.
Use spooky voices. When you tell the story, change your voice to a low, raspy tone for the scary parts. It immediately grabs the attention of the listeners.
Use different voices for different characters. For example, make your voice low and raspy for a spooky monster. This will immediately draw the kids in.
Use a lot of sound effects. For example, if you're telling a story about a creaky old house, make creaking noises while you're talking. It really sets the mood.
Use suspense. For example, don't reveal the monster right away. Build up the tension by describing strange noises or small, unexplained events first.
They can use sound effects. For example, if there's a part in the story about a howling wind, one kid can make a whooshing sound. It makes the story feel more real.
Use lots of sound effects. For example, if you're telling a story about a werewolf, make growling noises. And for the funny part, like when the werewolf slips on a banana peel (yes, in the middle of the forest), make a big 'whoosh' sound as it slides. Also, act out the parts. Wave your hands like the werewolf's paws or hunch over like an old witch.
Create a spooky atmosphere around the campfire. Dim the lights if possible, and use some props like fake spiders or a plastic skeleton. As you tell the story, gesture towards these props at the appropriate times. The physical setting will enhance the overall experience of the story and make it more engaging for kids.
One scary boy scout campfire story could be about a phantom hiker. Legend has it that in the very woods where the scouts are camping, there's a figure that appears at night. It's a hiker who got lost decades ago and never found his way out. Scouts have reported seeing a faint silhouette moving between the trees, and sometimes they hear the rustling of leaves as if someone is walking, but when they shine their flashlights, there's nothing there.
Create vivid characters in your stories. Give them names, personalities and backstories. This makes the audience care more about what happens to them. Use sound effects if possible, like snapping a twig to mimic a spooky noise in the story. And end your story with a cliffhanger or a really unexpected twist to leave your audience thinking about it long after the campfire is out.
Adding details to the description helps a lot. Instead of just saying 'a spooky house', describe it as 'a dilapidated, creaking house with broken windows and a sagging roof. The wind whistled through the cracks, making an eerie sound'. This paints a vivid picture in the kids' minds and makes the story more engaging.