Twilight: Edward vs Jacob Fanfiction - Who is more appealing in fanfiction?

One common plotline is a love triangle where the female character, often Bella, is torn between Edward and Jacob. The fanfiction might explore different outcomes of this triangle, like her choosing Jacob instead of Edward which is a big deviation from the original story.

The appeal of 'Twilight Jacob and Edward Fanfiction' lies in the chance to explore the relationship between these two complex characters further. In the original books, their dynamic was somewhat limited. Fanfiction allows for new scenarios and emotions.

In Twilight fanfiction, Edward is often depicted as the brooding, vampire hero. He's complex, with his struggle between his love for Bella and his vampire nature. Jacob, on the other hand, is the warm - hearted werewolf. Fanfictions might explore their relationship in different ways. Sometimes they are rivals, fiercely competing for Bella's love. In other stories, they might find a way to coexist or even become friends, despite their natural enmity in the original series.

There's also 'Twilight Reimagined: Edward and Jacob'. In this one, the author completely reimagines the story. Edward and Jacob are forced to work together in a world where the Volturi are more powerful than ever. It has a lot of great character development and the plot twists keep you on your toes.

A recurring theme is the concept of loyalty. Fans often write about how Edward and Jacob are loyal to their own kind and how that loyalty affects their relationship with Bella. Additionally, the idea of sacrifice comes up. Whether it's Edward being willing to sacrifice his own happiness for Bella's safety or Jacob making sacrifices in his own way for her. There are also fanfictions that focus on the cultural differences between the vampires and werewolves, which adds another layer to the Edward vs Jacob dynamic.

One popular trope is the 'rivalry turned friendship'. In many fanfictions, Edward and Jacob start off as bitter rivals for Bella's affection. But as the story progresses, they realize they have more in common than they thought. Another trope is the 'alternate universe' where their roles are reversed. For example, Edward could be a werewolf and Jacob a vampire. It's a fun way to play with the established characters.

The allure of this type of fanfiction is that it can provide a deeper understanding of Jacob. In a slash relationship, his personality can be explored in ways that might not have been possible in the original Twilight books. His interactions with another character can be more intense, emotional, and complex, which is very engaging for readers who want to see more of Jacob's internal world.

The fanfiction world gives the opportunity to create new storylines. Maybe in one fanfic, Bella ends up with both in a polyamorous relationship, or she chooses neither and goes off on her own adventure. There are endless possibilities, which is what makes it so appealing.

Well, a lot of Jacob Edward Twilight fanfiction delves into the idea of them finding common ground. In some stories, they end up becoming friends despite their initial rivalry over Bella. There are fanfictions where they have to team up against a new threat in the vampire - werewolf world that is even more powerful than the Volturi. These stories often play with the characters' personalities and expand on the lore of the Twilight universe.

You can start by looking on fanfiction websites such as Archive of Our Own (AO3). It has a vast collection of Twilight fanfiction, including those centered around Jacob and Edward. Another option is FanFiction.net, which has been around for a long time and has a large number of stories in the Twilight fandom.