One idea could be a modern - day retelling where the human characters take on the roles of the animals in Oliver and Company. For example, a street - smart kid could be Oliver, trying to survive in a big city. Another could be a story where the human characters form a rescue team to save the animals from an evil corporation that wants to use them for experiments. And a third idea might be a story about a human who befriends the animals and together they go on a musical adventure across the city.
A great plot for Oliver and Company fanfiction could be that the group stumbles upon a time - traveling device. They accidentally get sent back in time to when the city was first founded. There, they meet the ancestors of the current animals in the city. Dodger has to figure out how to get them all back to their own time while also dealing with the differences in the way animals lived back then. They might also have to avoid being caught by the early settlers who don't understand that they are intelligent animals.
One idea could be a story where Oliver gets lost in the big city again, but this time he meets a new group of animals who are into music like his friends in the original story. They form a makeshift band on the streets and try to make it big.
One idea could be that they discover the pregnancy during a mission. Maybe they're on a dangerous quest and Sara starts feeling unwell. It turns out she's pregnant, and they have to quickly figure out how to protect the baby while still completing their mission. Another plot could be that they initially struggle with the idea of becoming parents, given their dangerous lifestyles. They might worry about bringing a child into a world full of threats. A third idea is that their friends find out before they do, and there are some comical misunderstandings and attempts to break the news to them in a gentle way.
A really engaging plot might be that the pregnancy is the result of some sort of magical or alien influence. They initially struggle to accept it, but as time goes on, they start to embrace the new life coming. Their friends and allies might have mixed reactions, some being overjoyed while others are worried about how it will affect their superhero status. This could lead to a lot of character development and interesting relationships within the fanfiction.
One idea could be them facing challenges in their married life due to Oliver's vigilante duties. Maybe Felicity gets worried every time he goes out at night. Another could be them planning to start a family and all the joys and concerns that come with it. Or perhaps they take a trip together and encounter some old enemies during their journey.
Perhaps in the fanfiction, Hermione and Oliver are from different social classes in the wizarding world. The pregnancy makes them face the prejudices and expectations of their respective backgrounds. For example, Oliver might be from a pure - blood family with certain traditions, and Hermione being a Muggle - born, they have to deal with the reactions of his family. They could also have a journey where they explore different magical parenting techniques and meet other magical families who help or hinder them in their path to becoming parents.
In the fanfiction, it could be that the kiss was a mistake. They were both looking for someone else in the dark and accidentally kissed. But then, they find that there's an unexpected spark between them. They then have to deal with the consequences, like how to face their real intended partners and also their growing feelings for each other.
One common plot idea is the 'what if' scenario. For example, what if Laurel had survived in the show? Writers might explore how her relationship with Oliver would have developed further. Maybe they would have finally gotten married and had a family.
One idea could be that they face challenges in their relationship while Laurel is pregnant. Maybe Oliver is worried about his vigilante life affecting their unborn child. Another could be that they discover some sort of mystery related to Laurel's pregnancy, like a new threat in the city that targets pregnant women. A third plot idea might be that they have to deal with family reactions to the pregnancy, some being happy and others being worried about their future.
One plot idea could be that Hermione, using her magic, ends up in the Arrowverse and meets Oliver Queen. She helps him with some of his more difficult battles using her spells and intelligence. For example, she could use a spell to disarm his enemies from a distance.