There was a lonely forest that no one dared to enter after sunset. A group of hikers, though, decided to be adventurous. As they walked deeper into the forest, the trees seemed to close in around them. They heard howls that didn't sound like any normal animal. Then, they found a small, abandoned cabin. Inside, there was a single candle burning on a table. There was no sign of anyone living there, but the candle was fresh. One of the hikers blew it out, and suddenly, they all felt a sense of dread. They quickly left the cabin, but as they walked away, they could swear they heard footsteps following them. They never went back to that forest again.
I'm not sure specifically which '5 open ended stories' you are referring to. There could be countless open - ended stories out there. Maybe you could give a bit more context like who wrote them or what the general theme is.
Open ended spooky stories are interesting because they leave room for your imagination to run wild. You can come up with your own endings, which makes the story more personal. For example, in a story where a character enters a haunted house and hears strange noises but the story doesn't tell you what's really there, you can imagine all sorts of things like ghosts, demons or just some natural but creepy phenomenon.
A story that starts with a mysterious letter arriving at a person's doorstep. The letter has no return address and is written in an unknown language. The person then has to decide what to do with it. They could try to decipher it, or take it to an expert. There are so many directions the story could go from there. It's a great open ended story as it makes the reader wonder about the contents of the letter and what it could lead to.
There was a story of a cursed pumpkin patch. Every Halloween night, the pumpkins in that patch would come to life. They would roll around the field with their carved faces glowing an evil red, chasing anyone who dared to enter the patch. It was said that a farmer had once angered a powerful spirit in that very land.
One spooky ghost story is about an old mansion. People say that at midnight, a lady in a white dress can be seen wandering the halls. She was a bride who died on her wedding day many years ago. Another story is of a haunted forest. Travelers often hear strange whispers and see shadowy figures. It is said that a group of lost settlers died there long ago.
A group of campers once told a story of a cabin in the woods that was always locked. One night, they heard banging from inside the cabin. When they finally got the courage to look through the window, they saw a pair of red eyes staring back at them.
One spooky Christmas story is about a haunted Christmas tree. A family brought home a beautiful tree, but at night, they heard strange rustling sounds coming from it. When they investigated, they saw shadowy figures among the branches as if something was trapped inside. Eventually, they had to get rid of the tree to end the spooky happenings.
One dark spooky story is about an old abandoned house on the edge of town. People say that at midnight, you can see a faint light in the attic window. A young couple once decided to explore it. As they entered, they heard strange creaking sounds. Suddenly, a cold wind blew through the hallway, even though all the windows were boarded up. They ran out in terror, never to return.
During World War I, in the trenches, there were reports of strange noises at night. Soldiers would hear whispers that seemed to come from nowhere. In some areas, it was said that a shadowy figure would be seen moving along the trenches, but when the soldiers shone their lights, there was nothing there. These spooky occurrences were likely due to the extreme stress and trauma the soldiers were experiencing, but they still make for very eerie stories.
There's a spooky story about a dark forest. Hikers who enter it often report hearing whispers that seem to lead them astray. Legend has it that a coven of witches once lived in the forest and cursed it, so any who wander in are in danger of getting lost forever.