What do you think of the idea of 'Harry Potter beat Dumbledore to death' in fanfiction?

The idea is completely against the spirit of the 'Harry Potter' series. Dumbledore was Harry's support, helping him navigate the dangerous wizarding world. Fanfiction should enhance the understanding and enjoyment of the original work, not introduce such uncomfortable and untrue concepts. It's important to respect the characters and the world J.K. Rowling created.

I haven't come across such a disturbing fanfiction myself. In the official 'Harry Potter' lore, Harry and Dumbledore have a mentor - mentee relationship and there's no such violent scenario. Fanfiction that goes against the core values of the original work like this is not only untrue to the spirit but also quite abnormal.

This kind of idea in fanfiction shows a misunderstanding of the essence of 'Harry Potter'. The story is about growing up, facing challenges, and the power of love and friendship. Imposing such an unorthodox and improper relationship concept not only violates the integrity of the characters but also goes against what the series has been trying to convey to its readers.

Often, Dumbledore as Death would be a very complex character. He may not be the straightforward evil or good. His role might be more about maintaining a balance in the wizarding world, which is similar to the concept of Death in some mythologies. He could be using his influence on the different characters in different ways. For instance, his relationship with Snape could be a part of his plan as Death. Snape's actions, which were so crucial in the original story, might be reimagined as being directly or indirectly guided by Dumbledore - as - Death. This could add a whole new layer of mystery and intrigue to the fanfiction.

Well, it's just not right. Harry Potter's story is filled with themes of love, loyalty, and the fight against dark forces. His relationship with Petunia is part of his backstory that shows his difficult upbringing. Imaginings like Harry impregnating Petunia are not only against the natural order of the relationships in the story but also against basic moral and ethical principles. Fanfiction writers should focus on creating stories that respect the source material and promote positive values, rather than coming up with such improper scenarios.

It's a rather strange and inappropriate idea. Harry Potter is a beloved character, and this kind of scenario is disrespectful to his character. Fanfiction should enhance the world of Harry Potter, not create such demeaning situations.

It's completely wrong. The Harry Potter series is aimed at a wide audience, including children. This kind of inappropriate content has no place in fanfiction related to the series.

It's a rather strange and inappropriate idea. Harry and Snape have a complex relationship in the original series, and this concept distorts that relationship in an unseemly way. Fanfiction should enhance the world of the original work, not introduce such out - of - place and improper scenarios.

One key plot point could be Dumbledore's true identity being revealed gradually. Maybe Harry starts noticing strange things about Dumbledore that make him suspect he is not just an ordinary wizard but Death itself. Another could be how the prophecy about Harry and Voldemort fits into this new paradigm where Dumbledore is Death. It might change the meaning of the prophecy completely, as Dumbledore - as - Death could have a different intention behind the events related to the prophecy.

Well, 'Harry Potter' has a very specific and well - defined plot and world - building. It's about a boy wizard's fight against the dark wizard Voldemort. There are elements of mystery, adventure, and coming - of - age. Death is just one aspect among many in the story, and the overall story is far from being a death fanfiction. The series is more about the power of love and friendship in the face of evil.