What do you think about the idea of Snape stunning Hermione by kissing her in fanfiction?

I think it's an interesting concept. In the original series, their relationship was mainly platonic, but in fanfic, it allows for a different exploration of their characters and potential relationships. It can add a new layer of drama and romance.

There could be. Fanfiction allows for all kinds of wild and different interpretations of characters and their relationships. Snape is a complex character and Hermione is a strong - willed one. The idea of Snape stunning Hermione by kissing her is quite out - of - the - box. It may not be a common or widely - known fanfiction plot, but in the huge realm of fan - created stories, it could exist.

This is an inappropriate concept. In the Harry Potter series, Snape has his own role and relationship with Harry. He is often a figure of mystery and conflict towards Harry. The idea of such a non - consensual and inappropriate relationship is not only against the ethics of the story but also offensive to many fans who love the series for its positive values.

Fanfiction should focus on positive, healthy and creative storylines rather than such inappropriate scenarios. We should look for fanfictions that are in line with moral and ethical standards.

It's a rather controversial theme. In the original 'Harry Potter' series, Snape has a complex relationship with Hermione as a teacher - student. Such a romantic or physical interaction goes against the established power dynamics and character relationships in the canon, which is why it's likely to stir up strong opinions among fans.

One reason could be for the shock value. Writers might want to create a story that stands out from the more traditional fanfiction by presenting a very unexpected and taboo - like scenario. It grabs the readers' attention immediately.

This idea is just wrong. Fanfiction is supposed to be a creative extension of the original story, but this takes it in a very offensive direction. Hermione is meant to be a role model in the Harry Potter series, and this concept undermines all that she stands for. It also violates the basic respect that should be given to a well - loved character.

I think it could be both fun and controversial. On one hand, it gives fans the freedom to imagine a different kind of connection between Olive and Otto. On the other hand, some might feel it goes against the original platonic nature of their relationship in the show. But that's the beauty of fanfiction, it can take characters in new directions.

I think it's a rather dark and unfaithful take on the characters. In the original Harry Potter lore, Lily was in love with James. However, fanfiction is all about exploring different possibilities, but this one might not sit well with a lot of fans who have a more traditional view of the relationships.

This is a rather non - canonical and controversial concept within the Harry Potter fandom. However, there may be some fan - created works out there that explore such scenarios. But it goes against the traditional character dynamics presented in the original series.