What should one look for when critiquing fantasy stories?

One should look for vivid descriptions that bring the story world to life. Also, a balance between action and character development. And, of course, a story that leaves a lasting impression and makes you want to keep reading more.

Accuracy of information. If the story mentions a particular wine region, the grapes grown there should be correct. For example, if it's about Bordeaux, it should mention Cabernet Sauvignon and Merlot as the main grapes.

You should look for a unique theme or message in the fiction prose. Something that makes you think or feel differently after reading. Plus, good world-building can enhance the reading experience, creating a believable and immersive setting.

Characters matter a lot. Check if they're well-developed, believable, and have clear motivations and growth. Also, the writing style can affect the story's impact. Is it vivid and engaging?

You should look at the plot, the characters, and the writing style.

When reading fiction prose, you should look for vivid descriptions that make you feel like you're in the story. Also, good dialogue that reveals character and moves the story forward is key.

You should look for the language used, the emotions conveyed, and the overall atmosphere the story creates.

Students should look for interesting characters and a compelling plot. A good story makes you want to keep reading.

Students should look for elements like unique settings, thought-provoking ideas, and good writing style. A well-written fiction often combines these aspects to engage the reader fully.

It depends on the effect you want to create. Sometimes showing is better for immersing the reader in the moment, while telling can be quicker for conveying background info.