There could be a tale where the man who can hear prayers is pursued by mysterious forces that want to exploit his gift. He has to fight to protect himself and others.
Maybe a story where the man who hears prayers uses this power for selfish reasons, leading to terrifying consequences. It could explore his descent into darkness.
Well, imagine a story where this man is initially scared of his unique ability, but then learns to embrace it and uses it to solve mysteries. Another possibility is a tale where his ability brings him unwanted attention and puts him in danger.
It could be a tale of a supernatural or paranormal ability. Maybe the man uses this ability to help people or gets into strange adventures because of it.
It could be a tale of a unique individual with a supernatural ability who uses it to help or face challenges related to people's prayers and eyes.
He might feel burdened or confused, not knowing how to handle the responsibility.
There's a story where a girl found some old, strange drawings in an abandoned house. The drawings were all of Slender Man. After that, she started having nightmares. In her dreams, Slender Man was standing at the end of her bed, just watching her. She woke up one night to see a shadow on her wall that looked like him, and it terrified her. She never went back to that abandoned house again.
One creepy man story is about a guy who used to lurk around the local park at night. He would just stand in the shadows, watching people pass by. Once, a woman was walking her dog late and noticed him. He started following her at a distance. She got really scared and ran to a nearby house. The owner called the police and when they searched for the man, he had disappeared.
One common element is the element of lurking. Like in many stories, the creepy man is often seen hiding in the shadows or just being in places where he doesn't seem to belong, like the park at night in my previous story.
One short creepy story is about a haunted doll. A girl found an old doll in the attic. At night, she would hear it giggling and its eyes seemed to follow her around the room.
There's a short creepy story. A doll in an antique shop always seemed to be looking at a particular corner. One customer bought it and took it home. That night, she woke up to find the doll sitting on her chest, staring at her with its cold, lifeless eyes. And then there is a story about a deserted school. A group of teenagers decided to explore it at night. They heard the sound of children laughing and chalk screeching on blackboards, but they were the only ones there.
In an old apartment building, there was an old man who hardly ever talked to anyone. His apartment always smelled musty. One day, a new tenant moved in next door. At night, he could hear the old man pacing back and forth. Sometimes, there were strange scratching noises coming from the old man's side. The new tenant was so creeped out that he ended up moving out after a few weeks.