It's criticized because it often changes the core essence of Harry's character and the original story's themes.
It could be because some fanfiction writers want to take a different approach and create a new storyline where Harry's role or perception is challenged.
Fem Harry in crossover fanfics often takes on a more independent and assertive role. This can lead to her making choices that differ from the expected path of the 'Wrong Boy Who Lived' concept. Additionally, the crossover element itself might introduce new elements and conflicts that shape her character and story differently.
Typically, such fanfiction plays with gender roles and expectations. It could involve new magical abilities or plot twists specific to the fem version of Harry. The world-building might also be expanded or altered to accommodate this change.
It could be because the author wanted to create a unique twist or challenge the traditional storyline. Maybe they thought it would add more drama and intrigue.
Well, this kind of fanfiction often reimagines Harry as a female and might explore different storylines and character developments due to the gender change.
It is complete. The story wraps up all the major plot points and gives a satisfying conclusion to the alternate take on the Harry Potter universe.
It usually involves a twist where a female character takes on the role of the chosen one instead of the traditional storyline. The story might explore different power dynamics and character developments.
The 'Wrong Boy Who Lived' idea gives room for creativity. It allows for different character developments and plotlines that deviate from the original canon, making for fresh and exciting reads.
It's popular because it creates a lot of drama. The idea of a female Harry being neglected adds an extra layer of pathos. People like to see characters overcome hardships, and this trope gives that opportunity.
There could be several reasons. One is simply to add drama. A lot of fanfiction writers thrive on creating conflict, and what better way to do that than by taking on one of the most beloved houses in the 'Harry Potter' series? Another reason might be personal bias. Perhaps the writer had a negative experience with someone who identified strongly with Gryffindor, or they just don't like the traits that are typically associated with Gryffindor, like impulsiveness, and they use fanfiction as a way to express their views.