Poe used several criteria when reviewing a short story. He looked at how well the story held the reader's attention, if the themes were clearly presented and explored, and if the ending was satisfying and made sense within the context of the story.
Poe's criteria for reviewing a short story included analyzing the story's originality, the effectiveness of its suspense or surprise elements, and how well it evoked emotional responses in the reader. He also considered the quality of the writing style and the overall coherence of the narrative.
Poe typically focused on elements like plot consistency, character development, and the use of language and imagery to review a short story.