We can conclude that the White Impermanence is a god who specializes in capturing good people who have not done evil in their lives and those who have died a good death, so that they can reincarnate. Although some folk tales believed that the White Impermanence was female, in fact, the Black and White Impermanence were both male. Therefore, we can't conclude whether White Impermanence is a good person or a bad person.
Black and White Impermanence had good and evil. According to folk legends and myths, the Black Impermanence and the White Impermanence were brothers. They were gods who specialized in catching evil spirits. The White Impermanence was usually smiling, bringing good luck to people, while the Black Impermanence had a serious expression and specialized in capturing evil ghosts. Their image and personality traits changed according to the different versions of the story. Therefore, the Black and White Ghosts had both good and bad sides.
There was no clear answer to the question of whether the Black and White Ghosts were good or bad. Different cultures and story versions had different views on the Black and White Ghosts and their characters. According to folk legends and myths, the Black Impermanence and the White Impermanence were brothers. They were gods who specialized in catching evil spirits. The White Impermanence usually brought good luck to people, while the Black Impermanence specialized in catching evil spirits. Some people thought that the Black and White Ghosts were good because they were the right-hand men of the King of Hell and represented justice and order. However, some people thought that the Black and White Ghosts were bad because they had no bottom line in doing things. They could betray anyone and had the characteristics of a great villain. Therefore, different people had different opinions on whether the Black and White Ghosts were good or bad.
The Black and White Ghosts were initially identified as bad guys in Painting of the Bad People of Jianghu, but as the plot developed, their image gradually became white. Their appearance brought a psychological blow to the protagonist, but the subsequent plot revealed their unfortunate experience and forced killing environment, which made the audience sympathize and understand them. Even though the Black and White Ghosts had a bad side to them, they also showed kindness, responsibility, and mutual help. Therefore, it could be said that the Black and White Ghosts were not completely bad people. Their images were gradually complicated and whitewashed in the plot.
We can conclude that the White Impermanence is a god who specializes in capturing good people who have not done evil in their lives and those who have died a good death, so that they can reincarnate. Although some folk tales believed that the White Impermanence was female, in fact, the Black and White Impermanence were both male. Therefore, we can't conclude whether White Impermanence is a good person or a bad person.
Black Impermanence and White Impermanence weren't siblings, but lovers. In Painting of the Bad People of Jianghu, they were portrayed as a pair of villains, and their feelings for each other grew stronger and stronger. They had experienced many difficulties and dangers, but they always helped and protected each other. Although there was no mention of their kissing, it could be inferred that they had an intimate relationship. Therefore, it could be said that Black Impermanence and White Impermanence were lovers.
Black Impermanence and White Impermanence were portrayed as a couple in Painting of the Bad People of the World. Their relationship grew stronger and stronger. They experienced many difficulties and dangers, but they always helped and protected each other. However, according to the information provided, there was no mention of Black Impermanence and White Impermanence kissing, so I don't know if they kissed.
The Black and White Ghosts were not biological siblings. They were orphans adopted by General Chang Jin under Zhu Wen and were not related by blood. After they were taken in by the Underworld Emperor, they became the Black and White Ghosts of the Underworld Cult, inseparable. Therefore, their relationship was that of a couple, not that of a biological brother and sister.
There were different opinions on whether the Black and White Ghosts in Bad People were a couple. Some documents indicated that they were in a relationship, while others indicated that they were only in a master-disciple relationship or a sibling relationship. However, there was not enough evidence to determine their true relationship. Therefore, it was impossible to determine if the Black and White Ghosts were a couple.
The Black and White Ghosts were not siblings. The Black and White Impermanences were described in Painting of the Bad People of Jianghu as a relationship of mutual dependence and trust, surpassing the boundaries of kinship and love. Although some people described them as a couple, officials had confirmed that they were not biological siblings. They were orphans adopted by Zhu Wen's subordinates and later became subordinates of the Dark Mysterious Cult. The two of them had gone through difficult situations and life-and-death tests. They helped and protected each other, and their feelings for each other grew stronger. Therefore, the Black and White Ghosts were not siblings.
The friendship between White Impermanence and Black Impermanence was very deep. White Impermanence and Black Impermanence had been good friends since they were young. The story between them was very touching. They had experienced life and death together, and they were like brothers, even more so than real brothers. On a rainy day, White Impermanence was drenched in the rain while trying to get an umbrella for Black Impermanence. In the end, he drowned. This story showed the spirit of sacrifice and deep friendship between them. In addition, according to the legend mentioned in the search results, White Impermanence and Black Impermanence were sworn brothers when they were alive. Their friendship was like the ancient mountains and rivers, and they lived and died together. They chose to protect each other in the face of death, showing their deep friendship. Therefore, it could be said that the friendship between the White Impermanence and the Black Impermanence was very strong and precious.